Mickstar wrote:
bondiblue wrote:
Rod Spooky Galt wrote:
If the only way to keep TDK at the end of the year is Zac Williams and our first rounder as a cap dump, would you do it?
Always thinking outside the square Galty.
Great idea.
Saints are throwing heaps of money at TDK; money we can't match.
But TDK wants to stay a Blue unless we decide to let him go (by offering a Tuohy like contract which he would have to refuse)
Geez , that Zac Touhy thing turned out well didn't it . No way known would i lowball Tom . I would offer him a good deal ( not a sky's the limit deal ) that would keep . Tom has faults as a player for sure but his upside is too good to ignore . In ruck terms he is a baby and in time he will be a star ......................
PS i agree with you Bondi on Rod Spooky Galt . Superstar poster . Doesn't come on here often but when he does its kapow type stuff . Obviously a bloke who knows his footy inside out like your goodself Bondi ............ how good is TC ?
Appreciate the compliments, gents. As always - the source is well considered.
I was an advocate last year for retaining TDK over Harry. That ship has since sailed, it appears the club have effectively made up their mind that he was the one that had to be squeezed out, so be it.
Fast forward a few months, and Pitto doesn't look like he's over his injuries, and no evidence to show Mirkov is going to make it as a player. I'm not sure it's a luxury we can afford to let go.
McGovern off the books next year, Martin one year to go of a heavily front-ended deal. Williams the only real option, which to me, the optics are poor in trading out a player off an ACL, but also probably a necessary evil, given the alternative of asking him to restructure his deal in similar circumstances is just as unethical. Also suspect the above two have been already factored into some other long term deals handed out.
Going very very early in suggesting it, but Weitering is another option. Was very ordinary after his shoulder injury last year. Three years to go on decent money, a real sell high proposition, given the Saints want to build a list profile around Mornington Peninsula kids, I could see us actually getting a very good pick back rather than parting with one and the cap space to keep TDK. I'd also rather rely on building a backline around Lewis Young in Weitering's absence, than I would a ruck division around Pitto's PCL.
If TDK goes, I'm not sure there's a lot on the market for ruckmen who would be available for what we have to reasonably offer TDK. Darcy is probably worth more, there's about 3 young rucks at GWS who all seem to have one very good attribute and average at the rest and are about two years behind TDK in their development, Naitanui looks cooked and I'd probably say no to O'Brien on the basis of the Jordan Petersen love alone. Ideally Rowan Marshall gets jack of Ross Lyon and has concerns regarding the TDK acquirement and requests to go the other way.