FarmerBlue wrote:
jezzarules wrote:
FarmerBlue wrote:
This line up looks good to me
B: Docherty Weitering McGovern
HB: Cottrell Young Saad
C: Setterfield Cripps O'Brien
HF: Cerra McKay Fisher
F: Silvagni Curnow Motlop
Foll: TDK Kennedy Walsh
Int: Newman Stocker Dow Durdin (Plowman)
Getting closer to our best side. Missing Pittonet Marchbank Williams Boyd Owies
What's your lineup with everyone available?
B: Boyd Young McGovern
HB: Docherty Weitering Saad
C: Williams Cripps O’Brien
HF: Durdin McKay Fisher
F: Silvagni Curnow Owies
Foll: Pittonet Hewett Walsh
Int: Kennedy Cerra Marchbank TDK (Cottrell)
Em: Motlop Newman Martin
That’s a pretty good team on paper. I don’t think anyone would dispute that’s the spine we want. The discussion points for me are:
* BP. Boyd or Stocker or Williams? I would have Williams ahead (just), but Boyd showed promise before his injury and I like Stocker’s touch of mongrel.
* Wings. Has Williams ever played on a wing for us? LOB has improved but is he good enough? We talk about our need for another tall defender and a ruck, but these ‘best 22’ teams always show me that we are short a quality winger (or two).
* 7th defender (off the bench). Is Marchbank the right fit for that role? I think I would move Williams to defence and have one of Boyd, Newman or Stocker as the 7th defender. The remaining two from that troika could be considered for a wing. Marchbank is another possible option for the wing (he played some games there during the Bolton years). Alternatively, play Martin (HF) and put Fisher on the wing? Or Cottrell on a wing and have Marchbank/Martin as sub? I keep coming back to the wings because I feel like the rest of the puzzle will resolve itself once we find those missing pieces…
williams doesn’t have the tank for a wing role the way our system uses the winger, often has to pop up as the last forward in a chain of possessions around the opposite wing and having to shut down an opposition forward in our D50.
way too much running and speed required. that’s the main reason Cotrell has been getting a go, very big tank for his age already and a good repeat sprinter (according to the stats sheet anyhow). harder to tell on afl replays with Ch7s obsession with the CUP shot.