Jon Ralph
@RalphyHeraldSun

I understand Hunter Clark had a concussion test post-match after his hit by Zach Williams. He passed the SCAT test but almost certainly its enough to elevate the force. Looks likely to miss Round 1 against Tigers.
The look of the hit, the reality he jumped off the ground and the fact it was forceful enough to require a concussion test (which he passed) all cumulatively add up to what is likely to be medium impact and a week’s suspension

Not sure what you're looking for as Plow is a popular player on this board but I think he did his stopper job well. Killed almost everything in the air - was never loose on his opponents but always plays on zippy players like Higgins. When he got the ball hit his targets... he is what he is a non flashy stopper.

For Round 1
Back 7 Locked in, Weitering, Jones, Plowman, Docherty, SPS, Saad, Willo
Mids/Ruck 8 Locked in: Pitto, Cripps, Williams, Ed, Walsh, Dow, Setters, Newnes (if fit)
Forwards 6 locked in: McKay (assume fit), Fish, Murphy, Martin, Levi/Oscar (as ruck/2nd tall fwd), JSOS

Cusp - One or Two of Betts, Gov, Fogarty, O'Brien, Cunningham, Gibbons

Jon Ralph
@RalphyHeraldSun

I understand Hunter Clark had a concussion test post-match after his hit by Zach Williams. He passed the SCAT test but almost certainly its enough to elevate the force. Looks likely to miss Round 1 against Tigers.
The look of the hit, the reality he jumped off the ground and the fact it was forceful enough to require a concussion test (which he passed) all cumulatively add up to what is likely to be medium impact and a week’s suspension

Jon Ralph is a Richmond supporter yeah?

Saints should be fined for not having him sit the test immediately after the hit.
Why didn't the knob make that the focal point of his statement.

Yep

and he passed the concussion test, played out the rest of the game and was one of their best = LOW impact

Barely got off the ground with little force and elbow tucked in...............talk about dramatise.Robbo at his biased best.Why doesn't he apply the blowtorch to his Bomber mates...........scandalous what they have done,like nothing in footy before.A systematic doping program and that hypocrite of hypocrite's Robbo has still not followed it up cause he might upset his mates.More worried a bout a half hearted semi hip and shoulder.................How the faaark does he keep his job ?

Tom Browne
@TomBrowne7
Silvagni’s tackle on Sinclair is an a early test case for the MRO. Sinclair was fine, and I personally don’t think it’s worth a week. But some strong indications the mro has looked at it. We’ll find out this afternoon

https://twitter.com/TomBrowne7/status/1 ... 6234742789

Tom Browne
@TomBrowne7
Silvagni’s tackle on Sinclair is an a early test case for the MRO. Sinclair was fine, and I personally don’t think it’s worth a week. But some strong indications the mro has looked at it. We’ll find out this afternoon

https://twitter.com/TomBrowne7/status/1 ... 6234742789

FMD

Unless there's a strike with a clenched fist (coz open hands don't mean a thing) or elbow, or kick or spit or a bite, the MRO should just look at the injured, then narrow it down to head knocks, then determine if they missed time during game because of this injury opr played on.

The reason the MRO couldnt suspend players for not causing injury is because all the close ones, that didn't injured would have more than a dozen players rubbed out every week.

If the SOS tackle or the Williams tap sets a precedent, players are going to be fearful to play the game the same as they have, then its all over red rover. The game becomes netball, and we have lost our game.

SPS had a head knock...I bet it isn't even looked at.

I expect warnings today. That's it.

SPS had a head knock...I bet it isn't even looked at.

I expect warnings today. That's it.