TalkingCarlton :: View topic - R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)

Eddies last game too. Noise is getting louder from the regulars at BF.

The Normal One wrote:

Eddies last game too. Noise is getting louder from the regulars at BF.

I hope so, who wants to see Beets managed/dropped in 2021. Deserves better, the club achieved what they wanted from Eddie, let's send him and Simmo of in style Sat night.

The Normal One wrote:

Eddies last game too. Noise is getting louder from the regulars at BF.

I hope so, who wants to see Beets managed/dropped in 2021. Deserves better, the club achieved what they wanted from Eddie, let's send him and Simmo of in style Sat night.

Eddies last game too. Noise is getting louder from the regulars at BF.

Doc & Fish out, Martin should play-

https://www.carltonfc.com.au/news/81408 ... tin-likely

I hope we blood a kid (Ramsay?) or get another game into Cottrell, Honey or Philp.

But we’ll probably play Polson instead.

Whether you like it or not SOss legacy continues
I would love to see some massive changes
Make a statement

Won’t happen
The future
Ramsay
Cottrell
Honey
Philp
Kemp
Teague has to put faith in youth
We desperately need run
We sadly lack offensively defensively
We are a good contested ball team but the other stuff
Crap
Teague must make a statement
I would love to see him make wholesale changes

keogh wrote:

Those three statements do NOT belong in the same post.
If SOS mucked it up so badly, why are they the future and why do you want to see them playing?
If your logic stood up, you wouldn't want them anywhere near the park.
I applaud your passion but there is no need to include the fact you think SOS was a failure in every single post.
We get that part of your argument already.

Blue Sombrero wrote:

keogh wrote:

Why not?
I want his 2019 crop which are mostly mids picked to see what they have got
Because his strike are with mids is terrible

Two things
Remember the the press conference in 2015
From memory there was Bolton SOS the President
Bolton sacked SoS cracks it and leaves but the Pres remains
It’s still a boys club

SOS said he would rebuild. The Pres said we had learnt from our mistakes we have listened to our supporters (which includes you and me) and there will be no more quick fixes

They lied.
Replacing spuds with spuds
McGovern
Cogs
Shiel
Bolton took the fall because SOS was a protected species

Will anything change under Austin
Other than trying some kids and cheering Simmo off I couldn’t give a shit about this game.

I am more interested in what Austin’s strategy is and does Teague puts his faith and trust in the guys SOS recruited

Last year Richmonds premiership team had 9 players who were
Pick 50 or lower
Rookies
Pre season picks
Marion Pickett
Mid season draft
You can draw your own conclusions from that

Not sure what we gain from playing half a dozen kids at once. Lambs to the slaughter. They should have been used more during the year.

So is it Eddie's last game or isn't it?

keogh wrote:

Blue Sombrero wrote:

keogh wrote:

Blue Sombrero is right. Conflicting. You should know that with your background.

The yellow: so you can write off 19yo's like you are 20yo 21 yo 22yo 23yo?
Really unhealthy stuff for players to have to put up with, let alone us supporters, coz its not right in that its not timely.

Green highlight...I don't get how you conclude "Boys Club" from what you posted.
That did what they set out to do. Have I missed something?

McGovern, we know he hasn't performed, but it was the only player with a strong body and a good highlights package we could attract after failing to get the others you mentioned Cogs Shiel: so did 16 other teams. I'm sure they did their best, and if it meant getting them on a plane, thank god we have one of those. We lost Shiel to a Business offer in Finance. Like Worsfold is pointing out, [just because you're a big four, it doesn't mean its all handed to you]

keogh wrote:

Blue Sombrero wrote:

keogh wrote:

rhino27 wrote:

So is it Eddie's last game or isn't it?

Its a [REDACTED] situation, isn't it!

Do you know what the list sizes are?

No one does.

Thanks for nothing Gil.

Author:	Blue4ever [ Wed Sep 16, 2020 12:28 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)
The Normal One wrote: Eddies last game too. Noise is getting louder from the regulars at BF. I hope so, who wants to see Beets managed/dropped in 2021. Deserves better, the club achieved what they wanted from Eddie, let's send him and Simmo of in style Sat night.

Author:	CFC8795 [ Wed Sep 16, 2020 12:33 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)
Blue4ever wrote: The Normal One wrote: Eddies last game too. Noise is getting louder from the regulars at BF. I hope so, who wants to see Beets managed/dropped in 2021. Deserves better, the club achieved what they wanted from Eddie, let's send him and Simmo of in style Sat night. Anyone else while we're at it?

Author:	carntheblues [ Wed Sep 16, 2020 2:10 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)
Yes it would be great to send them both off in style with a great win.

Author:	cortez [ Wed Sep 16, 2020 2:54 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)
Blue4ever wrote: The Normal One wrote: Eddies last game too. Noise is getting louder from the regulars at BF. I hope so, who wants to see Beets managed/dropped in 2021. Deserves better, the club achieved what they wanted from Eddie, let's send him and Simmo of in style Sat night. What would be even worse would be seeing Eddie playing when his form didn't warrant it. We all love you Eddie, go now, too many players hang around a little too long.

Author:	blue5 [ Wed Sep 16, 2020 3:18 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)
We all got a dream come true to see Eddie Betts in navy blue again....loved every minute of it, but the show must end. Find him a role at the club, mentor future forward pockets and hopefully one day we get to see another Betts in blue!

TalkingCarlton http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/

R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion) http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=37006	Page 4 of 9

Author:	bondiblue [ Wed Sep 16, 2020 3:19 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)
The Normal One wrote: Eddies last game too. Noise is getting louder from the regulars at BF. Its so wrong he's forced to stand down all because the AFL Commission hasn't informed the clubs what the list sizes are for 2021. I hope we can squeeze him in as a rookie. Get his photo on the 200 gamer wall at HQ The only other indigenous player to make it was Andrew "sky" walker who got to 202 games.

Author:	aboynamedsue [ Wed Sep 16, 2020 5:16 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)
Doc & Fish out, Martin should play- https://www.carltonfc.com.au/news/81408 ... tin-likely I hope we blood a kid (Ramsay?) or get another game into Cottrell, Honey or Philp. But we’ll probably play Polson instead.

Author:	CC1961 [ Wed Sep 16, 2020 8:05 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)
They're kind of 'consistent' in a way: They go from NOT kicking a goal in the LAST for two weeks to not kicking one in the First for the next two. Total lottery for this next one. on a "Hatrick" for a goal-less 1st quarter...

Author:	bondiblue [ Wed Sep 16, 2020 9:42 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)
aboynamedsue wrote: Doc & Fish out, Martin should play- https://www.carltonfc.com.au/news/81408 ... tin-likely I hope we blood a kid (Ramsay?) or get another game into Cottrell, Honey or Philp. But we’ll probably play Polson instead. Would be great. my dream before the long break.

Author:	keogh [ Wed Sep 16, 2020 10:52 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)
Whether you like it or not SOss legacy continues I would love to see some massive changes Make a statement Won’t happen The future Ramsay Cottrell Honey Philp Kemp Teague has to put faith in youth We desperately need run We sadly lack offensively defensively We are a good contested ball team but the other stuff Crap Teague must make a statement I would love him to make wholesale changes

Author:	Blue Sombrero [ Thu Sep 17, 2020 12:21 am ]
Post subject:	Re: R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)
keogh wrote: Whether you like it or not SOss legacy continues I would love to see some massive changes Make a statement Won’t happen The future Ramsay Cottrell Honey Philp Kemp Teague has to put faith in youth We desperately need run We sadly lack offensively defensively We are a good contested ball team but the other stuff Crap Teague must make a statement I would love to see him make wholesale changes Those three statements do NOT belong in the same post. If SOS mucked it up so badly, why are they the future and why do you want to see them playing? If your logic stood up, you wouldn't want them anywhere near the park. I applaud your passion but there is no need to include the fact you think SOS was a failure in every single post. We get that part of your argument already.

Author:	keogh [ Thu Sep 17, 2020 7:28 am ]
Post subject:	Re: R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)
Blue Sombrero wrote: keogh wrote: Whether you like it or not SOss legacy continues I would love to see some massive changes Make a statement Won’t happen The future Ramsay Cottrell Honey Philp Kemp Teague has to put faith in youth We desperately need run We sadly lack offensively defensively We are a good contested ball team but the other stuff Crap Teague must make a statement I would love to see him make wholesale changes Those three statements do NOT belong in the same post. If SOS mucked it up so badly, why are they the future and why do you want to see them playing? If your logic stood up, you wouldn't want them anywhere near the park. I applaud your passion but there is no need to include the fact you think SOS was a failure in every single post. We get that part of your argument already. Why not? I want his 2019 crop which are mostly mids picked to see what they have got Because his strike are with mids is terrible Two things Remember the the press conference in 2015 From memory there was Bolton SOS the President Bolton sacked SoS cracks it and leaves but the Pres remains It’s still a boys club SOS said he would rebuild. The Pres said we had learnt from our mistakes we have listened to our supporters (which includes you and me) and there will be no more quick fixes They lied. Replacing spuds with spuds McGovern Cogs Shiel Bolton took the fall because SOS was a protected species Will anything change under Austin Other than trying some kids and cheering Simmo off I couldn’t give a shit about this game. I am more interested in what Austin’s strategy is and does Teague puts his faith and trust in the guys SOS recruited Last year Richmonds premiership team had 9 players who were Pick 50 or lower Rookies Pre season picks Marion Pickett Mid season draft You can draw your own conclusions from that

Author:	Navy Blue Horse [ Thu Sep 17, 2020 10:31 am ]
Post subject:	Re: R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)
Not sure what we gain from playing half a dozen kids at once. Lambs to the slaughter. They should have been used more during the year.

Author:	rhino27 [ Thu Sep 17, 2020 10:41 am ]
Post subject:	Re: R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)
So is it Eddie's last game or isn't it?

Page 4 of 9	All times are UTC + 10 hours
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/

Author:	bondiblue [ Thu Sep 17, 2020 11:07 am ]
Post subject:	Re: R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)
keogh wrote: Blue Sombrero wrote: keogh wrote: Whether you like it or not SOss legacy continues I would love to see some massive changes Make a statement Won’t happen The future Ramsay Cottrell Honey Philp Kemp Teague has to put faith in youth We desperately need run We sadly lack offensively defensively We are a good contested ball team but the other stuff Crap Teague must make a statement I would love to see him make wholesale changes Those three statements do NOT belong in the same post. If SOS mucked it up so badly, why are they the future and why do you want to see them playing? If your logic stood up, you wouldn't want them anywhere near the park. I applaud your passion but there is no need to include the fact you think SOS was a failure in every single post. We get that part of your argument already. Why not? I want his 2019 crop which are mostly mids picked to see what they have got Because his strike are with mids is terrible Two things Remember the the press conference in 2015 From memory there was Bolton SOS the President Bolton sacked SoS cracks it and leaves but the Pres remains It’s still a boys club SOS said he would rebuild. The Pres said we had learnt from our mistakes we have listened to our supporters (which includes you and me) and there will be no more quick fixes They lied. Replacing spuds with spuds McGovern Cogs Shiel Bolton took the fall because SOS was a protected species Will anything change under Austin Other than trying some kids and cheering Simmo off I couldn’t give a shit about this game. I am more interested in what Austin’s strategy is and does Teague puts his faith and trust in the guys SOS recruited Last year Richmonds premiership team had 9 players who were Pick 50 or lower Rookies Pre season picks Marion Pickett Mid season draft You can draw your own conclusions from that Blue Sombrero is right. Conflicting. You should know that with your background. The yellow: so you can write off 19yo's like you are 20yo 21 yo 22yo 23yo? Really unhealthy stuff for players to have to put up with, let alone us supporters, coz its not right in that its not timely. Green highlight...I don't get how you conclude "Boys Club" from what you posted. That did what they set out to do. Have I missed something? McGovern, we know he hasn't performed, but it was the only player with a strong body and a good highlights package we could attract after failing to get the others you mentioned Cogs Shiel: so did 16 other teams. I'm sure they did their best, and if it meant getting them on a plane, thank god we have one of those. We lost Shiel to a Business offer in Finance. Like Worsfold is pointing out, [just because you're a big four, it doesn't mean its all handed to you]

Author:	bondiblue [ Thu Sep 17, 2020 11:09 am ]
Post subject:	Re: R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)
Navy Blue Horse wrote: Not sure what we gain from playing half a dozen kids at once. Lambs to the slaughter. They should have been used more during the year. Proves they have learned from the pass...maybe gone too hard the other way though. I can live with that, as long as the kids are developed properly and decision making philosophy improves.

Author:	bondiblue [ Thu Sep 17, 2020 11:10 am ]
Post subject:	Re: R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)
rhino27 wrote: So is it Eddie's last game or isn't it? Its a [REDACTED] situation, isn't it! Do you know what the list sizes are? No one does. Thanks for nothing Gil.

Author:	keogh [ Thu Sep 17, 2020 11:49 am ]
Post subject:	Re: R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)
bondiblue wrote: keogh wrote: Blue Sombrero wrote: keogh wrote: Whether you like it or not SOss legacy continues I would love to see some massive changes Make a statement Won’t happen The future Ramsay Cottrell Honey Philp Kemp Teague has to put faith in youth We desperately need run We sadly lack offensively defensively We are a good contested ball team but the other stuff Crap Teague must make a statement I would love to see him make wholesale changes Those three statements do NOT belong in the same post. If SOS mucked it up so badly, why are they the future and why do you want to see them playing? If your logic stood up, you wouldn't want them anywhere near the park. I applaud your passion but there is no need to include the fact you think SOS was a failure in every single post. We get that part of your argument already. Why not? I want his 2019 crop which are mostly mids picked to see what they have got Because his strike are with mids is terrible Two things Remember the the press conference in 2015 From memory there was Bolton SOS the President Bolton sacked SoS cracks it and leaves but the Pres remains It’s still a boys club SOS said he would rebuild. The Pres said we had learnt from our mistakes we have listened to our supporters (which includes you and me) and there will be no more quick fixes They lied. Replacing spuds with spuds McGovern Cogs Shiel Bolton took the fall because SOS was a protected species Will anything change under Austin Other than trying some kids and cheering Simmo off I couldn’t give a shit about this game. I am more interested in what Austin’s strategy is and does Teague puts his faith and trust in the guys SOS recruited Last year Richmonds premiership team had 9 players who were Pick 50 or lower Rookies Pre season picks Marion Pickett Mid season draft You can draw your own conclusions from that Blue Sombrero is right. Conflicting. You should know that with your background. The yellow: so you can write off 19yo's like you are 20yo 21 yo 22yo 23yo? Really unhealthy stuff for players to have to put up with, let alone us supporters, coz its not right in that its not timely. Green highlight...I don't get how you conclude "Boys Club" from what you posted. That did what they set out to do. Have I missed something? McGovern, we know he hasn't performed, but it was the only player with a strong body and a good highlights package we could attract after failing to get the others you mentioned Cogs Shiel: so did 16 other teams. I'm sure they did their best, and if it meant getting them on a plane, thank god we have one of those. We lost Shiel to a Business offer in Finance. Like Worsfold is pointing out, [just because you're a big four, it doesn't mean its all handed to you] Oh I forgot Stephen Trigg Long gone to Why? How much more evidence do you need that the club has been unstable during our rebuild. The board give vague info when shit happens Empty suits BB

Author:	carntheblues [ Thu Sep 17, 2020 11:58 am ]
Post subject:	Re: R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)
bondiblue wrote: keogh wrote: Blue Sombrero wrote: keogh wrote: Whether you like it or not SOss legacy continues I would love to see some massive changes Make a statement Won’t happen The future Ramsay Cottrell Honey Philp Kemp Teague has to put faith in youth We desperately need run We sadly lack offensively defensively We are a good contested ball team but the other stuff Crap Teague must make a statement I would love to see him make wholesale changes Those three statements do NOT belong in the same post. If SOS mucked it up so badly, why are they the future and why do you want to see them playing? If your logic stood up, you wouldn't want them anywhere near the park. I applaud your passion but there is no need to include the fact you think SOS was a failure in every single post. We get that part of your argument already. Why not? I want his 2019 crop which are mostly mids picked to see what they have got Because his strike are with mids is terrible Two things Remember the the press conference in 2015 From memory there was Bolton SOS the President Bolton sacked SoS cracks it and leaves but the Pres remains It’s still a boys club SOS said he would rebuild. The Pres said we had learnt from our mistakes we have listened to our supporters (which includes you and me) and there will be no more quick fixes They lied. Replacing spuds with spuds McGovern Cogs Shiel Bolton took the fall because SOS was a protected species Will anything change under Austin Other than trying some kids and cheering Simmo off I couldn’t give a shit about this game. I am more interested in what Austin’s strategy is and does Teague puts his faith and trust in the guys SOS recruited Last year Richmonds premiership team had 9 players who were Pick 50 or lower Rookies Pre season picks Marion Pickett Mid season draft You can draw your own conclusions from that Blue Sombrero is right. Conflicting. You should know that with your background. The yellow: so you can write off 19yo's like you are 20yo 21 yo 22yo 23yo? Really unhealthy stuff for players to have to put up with, let alone us supporters, coz its not right in that its not timely. Green highlight...I don't get how you conclude "Boys Club" from what you posted. That did what they set out to do. Have I missed something? McGovern, we know he hasn't performed, but it was the only player with a strong body and a good highlights package we could attract after failing to get the others you mentioned Cogs Shiel: so did 16 other teams. I'm sure they did their best, and if it meant getting them on a plane, thank god we have one of those. We lost Shiel to a Business offer in Finance. Like Worsfold is pointing out, [just because you're a big four, it doesn't mean its all handed to you] Good post BB. I agree with the sentiment.

Author:	rhino27 [ Thu Sep 17, 2020 12:45 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R18 Brisbane v Carlton (pre match discussion)
bondiblue wrote: rhino27 wrote: So is it Eddie's last game or isn't it? Its a [REDACTED] situation, isn't it! Do you know what the list sizes are? No one does. Thanks for nothing Gil. Totally [REDCATED]. Do these tossers not care that these are people's livelihoods they are playing with?