TalkingCarlton
http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/

List Management 2020
http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=36699
Page 113 of 118

Author:  jamespul65 [ Fri Nov 13, 2020 12:56 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: List Management 2020

we need to start adding youngster to list or our future recruits should be under 25 ,worried that we have a solid group of 27 yrs old gives us 4 good years need to keep adding to our younger age group and keep list building. Look at tigers lost higgins and this supporter on sen mentioned about 3 players that can replace him .

Author:  SurreyBlue [ Fri Nov 13, 2020 3:37 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: List Management 2020

bondiblue wrote:
SurreyBlue wrote:
Agree Bondi. Williams will be a fantastic addition to our midfield. He is exactly what we need to complement Cripps, Setters, Kennedy. Don't worry about that. It's now up to Barker to f@#king set up and rotate them correctly.



...and Walsh, who should start in the middle every week, coz we got him for that role, he does aplomb, and, who starred in the middle in the 2nd half of the season....plenty of Brownlow votes says it all.

Back to your point, the players by-pass Barker when they leave his stoppages meeting and work it out themselves out on the field.

Kennedy...interesting.

He had 4th most attendances in the centre bounce this year, but was up for trade.

Yep, he's part of the squad. Can't see Kennedy playing many games in 2021 TBH...unless its wet.

He is versatile.


This Bondi:

SurreyBlue wrote:
Here is my 22"
Plowman Jones Marchbank
Docherty Weitering Saad
Williams Cripps SpS
Martin Casboult Fisher
JSoS McKay Betts
Pittonet Setterfield Walsh
Int: Kennedy (Inside Mid) Murphy, Dow, Williamson (runners)

Midfield rotations from the int and forward line.
* I'm not including Charlie. TDK will rotate with Pittonet as 1st ruck or Casboult as 2nd ruck.

Consider the players that can be included in the 22 from these sections and finals is non-negotiable:
Mature bodies:
McGovern, Ed Curnow, Newman, Newnes, Gibbons
Expecting players to push for best 22:
O’Brien, Stocker, Macreade, Polson, Fogarty
Developing Kids:
Kemp, Philp, Honey, Cottrell, Phillips, Ramsey

Author:  Walsh [ Fri Nov 13, 2020 4:07 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: List Management 2020

This is pretty good from the ABC - nice interesting stats of trade period that just passed.

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-11-13/ ... e/12877046

Author:  Donstuie [ Fri Nov 13, 2020 4:13 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: List Management 2020

I have no idea what any of that means, but it shows us beating everyone, so I like it :thumbsup:

Author:  bondiblue [ Sat Nov 14, 2020 11:45 am ]
Post subject:  Re: List Management 2020

Donstuie wrote:
I have no idea what any of that means, but it shows us beating everyone, so I like it :thumbsup:


That's what it says D. :thumbsup:

We can beat anyone over the next 10 years starting in 2021. :beer:

Author:  Crusader [ Sat Nov 14, 2020 1:02 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: List Management 2020

Main list currently on the maximum of 38 (including Gibbons) with Kennedy, Macreadie, Polson & Newnes out of contract.

Five of the maximum six rookies on the list, with Honey & Cottrell locked in. Phillips, Owies & Moore are out of contract.

The scouting reports suggest it's a good draft for defenders. Nevertheless, I think we'll need to keep both Macreadie & Moore around.

Newnes played every game in his first season and had a pretty good year. As did Kennedy, but he might opt to take his chances elsewhere if backup full forward is his only way into the side. Perhaps his fate was sealed when he hitched his wagon to Izzy Folau?

Kennedy, Polson, Phillips & Owies to be delisted. Macreadie & Moore retained on the rookie list.

Leaves room for three additions to the main list & up to two rookies.

Author:  sticksaftersiren87 [ Sat Nov 14, 2020 1:35 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: List Management 2020

I’d keep Kennedy and Newnes and only draft 2.

Macreadie rookie perhaps.

Polson, Moore and Philips delist

Author:  bondiblue [ Sat Nov 14, 2020 3:05 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: List Management 2020

Crusader wrote:
Main list currently on the maximum of 38 (including Gibbons) with Kennedy, Macreadie, Polson & Newnes out of contract.

Five of the maximum six rookies on the list, with Honey & Cottrell locked in. Phillips, Owies & Moore are out of contract.

The scouting reports suggest it's a good draft for defenders. Nevertheless, I think we'll need to keep both Macreadie & Moore around.

Newnes played every game in his first season and had a pretty good year. As did Kennedy, but he might opt to take his chances elsewhere if backup full forward is his only way into the side. Perhaps his fate was sealed when he hitched his wagon to Izzy Folau?

Kennedy, Polson, Phillips & Owies to be delisted. Macreadie & Moore retained on the rookie list.

Leaves room for three additions to the main list & up to two rookies.


How long do you expect Macreadie to last as a DFA prior to our turn to rookie him?

I reckon Cats will take him in the draft if he's there for the taking.

North should.

I think Betts sould be on the rookie list. No one will take him off us.

Newnes isn't out of contract. He had a 2 year offer with Saints and took our 2 year offer.

Author:  billc3 [ Sat Nov 14, 2020 10:32 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: List Management 2020

Crusader wrote:
Main list currently on the maximum of 38 (including Gibbons) with Kennedy, Macreadie, Polson & Newnes out of contract.

Five of the maximum six rookies on the list, with Honey & Cottrell locked in. Phillips, Owies & Moore are out of contract.

The scouting reports suggest it's a good draft for defenders. Nevertheless, I think we'll need to keep both Macreadie & Moore around.

Newnes played every game in his first season and had a pretty good year. As did Kennedy, but he might opt to take his chances elsewhere if backup full forward is his only way into the side. Perhaps his fate was sealed when he hitched his wagon to Izzy Folau?

Kennedy, Polson, Phillips & Owies to be delisted. Macreadie & Moore retained on the rookie list.

Leaves room for three additions to the main list & up to two rookies.
Can't see Kennedy being delisted.... Or Moore retained...

Go Blues

Author:  bondiblue [ Sun Nov 15, 2020 8:50 am ]
Post subject:  Re: List Management 2020

billc3 wrote:
Crusader wrote:
Main list currently on the maximum of 38 (including Gibbons) with Kennedy, Macreadie, Polson & Newnes out of contract.

Five of the maximum six rookies on the list, with Honey & Cottrell locked in. Phillips, Owies & Moore are out of contract.

The scouting reports suggest it's a good draft for defenders. Nevertheless, I think we'll need to keep both Macreadie & Moore around.

Newnes played every game in his first season and had a pretty good year. As did Kennedy, but he might opt to take his chances elsewhere if backup full forward is his only way into the side. Perhaps his fate was sealed when he hitched his wagon to Izzy Folau?

Kennedy, Polson, Phillips & Owies to be delisted. Macreadie & Moore retained on the rookie list.

Leaves room for three additions to the main list & up to two rookies.
Can't see Kennedy being delisted.... Or Moore retained...

Go Blues


My understanding is we don't have to take 3 picks in the draft this year: only one.

We have upgraded Gibbons, so there's our one compulsory selection in the draft.

To take anymore, Austin has to see opportunity with the two picks being an improvement on the likes of Polson, Kennedy and Moore.

Moore is supplentary...and therefore a rookie???? If so, he's a different category to Kennedy and Polson

Author:  bluechampion [ Sun Nov 15, 2020 10:50 am ]
Post subject:  Re: List Management 2020

The AFL hasn't explained exactly how it will work, but we also have to build a VFL list in 2021.

Author:  Crusader [ Sun Nov 15, 2020 1:59 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: List Management 2020

bondiblue wrote:
Crusader wrote:
Main list currently on the maximum of 38 (including Gibbons) with Kennedy, Macreadie, Polson & Newnes out of contract.

Five of the maximum six rookies on the list, with Honey & Cottrell locked in. Phillips, Owies & Moore are out of contract.

The scouting reports suggest it's a good draft for defenders. Nevertheless, I think we'll need to keep both Macreadie & Moore around.

Newnes played every game in his first season and had a pretty good year. As did Kennedy, but he might opt to take his chances elsewhere if backup full forward is his only way into the side. Perhaps his fate was sealed when he hitched his wagon to Izzy Folau?

Kennedy, Polson, Phillips & Owies to be delisted. Macreadie & Moore retained on the rookie list.

Leaves room for three additions to the main list & up to two rookies.


How long do you expect Macreadie to last as a DFA prior to our turn to rookie him?

I reckon Cats will take him in the draft if he's there for the taking.

North should.

I think Betts sould be on the rookie list. No one will take him off us.

Newnes isn't out of contract. He had a 2 year offer with Saints and took our 2 year offer.

Good news re Newnes.

We're the only club that would offer Macreadie a lifeline, though the new ressies comp might be enticing for him. New environment, new mentors... a fresh set of eyes and ears. Had we retained a top pick, somewhere under 25, I would've just delisted him & taken my chances in the draft.

In any case, the depth chart at KPD is pretty shallow.

Weitering, Jones.... Casboult out of position..... Marchbank & Plowman undersized........... Macreadie, Moore.

Author:  CarltonClem [ Sun Nov 15, 2020 2:58 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: List Management 2020

The wrist slashing here regarding giving up Saad for pick 8 would make you think we gave up pick 8 alone which is clearly not the case.

Given our list size, if we trade 38 and 48 for a late 20s pick, we’ve effectively traded 8 for Saad and late 20s with Fogarty as change. And we’ve landed the main targets we wanted and fulfilled our list obligations in the draft.

Stop looking at the Saad trade in isolation and only looking at the headline pick 8. Think objectively, not just because it was Essendon*/Dodo we were dealing with.

The clown couldn’t get the Dunkley deal done, has left him hanging and potentially his brother too.

Author:  ferdinand [ Sun Nov 15, 2020 7:48 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: List Management 2020

Surely they weren’t just picking his brother to get Josh there? They’ll still list him even though they didn’t get the deal done with the Dogs. Otherwise it would mean they were just using him as bait to get Josh and they’d never treat someone like that, would they?

Author:  bondiblue [ Sun Nov 15, 2020 8:56 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: List Management 2020

CarltonClem wrote:
The wrist slashing here regarding giving up Saad for pick 8 would make you think we gave up pick 8 alone which is clearly not the case.

Given our list size, if we trade 38 and 48 for a late 20s pick, we’ve effectively traded 8 for Saad and late 20s with Fogarty as change. And we’ve landed the main targets we wanted and fulfilled our list obligations in the draft.

Stop looking at the Saad trade in isolation and only looking at the headline pick 8. Think objectively, not just because it was Essendon**/Dodo we were dealing with.

The clown couldn’t get the Dunkley deal done, has left him hanging and potentially his brother too.


Right on babee.
That's a good way of viewing it.
Austin alluded to pick upgrade and the fact pick 78 will become pick under 50, hence points.

Yep, exactly as you say, there's more to it than looking at it in solation.
IT being pick 8.

Its done. There's 2 viewpoints. There always will be.
We are the winners for it, either way.

Go Blues

Author:  bondiblue [ Sun Nov 15, 2020 8:57 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: List Management 2020

ferdinand wrote:
Surely they weren’t just picking his brother to get Josh there? They’ll still list him even though they didn’t get the deal done with the Dogs. Otherwise it would mean they were just using him as bait to get Josh and they’d never treat someone like that, would they?


Pricks.

Good onya bringing this up.

Lets see.

Author:  bluechampion [ Mon Nov 16, 2020 9:32 am ]
Post subject:  Re: List Management 2020

jamespul65 wrote:
we need to start adding youngster to list or our future recruits should be under 25 ,worried that we have a solid group of 27 yrs old gives us 4 good years need to keep adding to our younger age group and keep list building. Look at tigers lost higgins and this supporter on sen mentioned about 3 players that can replace him .


Newman, Newnes and Docherty are the only 27 year-olds currently on our list.

Saad, Plowman, Williams and McGovern are all 26.

There are no 28 year-olds.

Author:  Navy Blue Horse [ Tue Nov 17, 2020 11:02 am ]
Post subject:  Re: List Management 2020

GET 28yos

Author:  dannyboy [ Tue Nov 17, 2020 11:38 am ]
Post subject:  Re: List Management 2020

just be patient the 28yos will come...

Author:  bondiblue [ Tue Nov 17, 2020 12:26 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: List Management 2020

bluechampion wrote:
jamespul65 wrote:
we need to start adding youngster to list or our future recruits should be under 25 ,worried that we have a solid group of 27 yrs old gives us 4 good years need to keep adding to our younger age group and keep list building. Look at tigers lost higgins and this supporter on sen mentioned about 3 players that can replace him .


Newman, Newnes and Docherty are the only 27 year-olds currently on our list.

Saad, Plowman, Williams and McGovern are all 26.

There are no 28 year-olds.


We will have three 28 yo's next year...Newman, Newnes and Docherty
We will have four 27 yo's next year...Saad, Plowman, Williams and McGovern

We will have no 36yo or 33yo next year.

Murphy will be 34yo and Betts 35yo next year.

Page 113 of 118 All times are UTC + 10 hours
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/