famousblueraincoat wrote:
BigKev wrote:
bluedog wrote:
This just posted yesterday on the CFC website.
https://www.carltonfc.com.au/video/2019-06-12/carlton-coaches-corner-jack-silvagniI'll say one thing about Silvagni J - he's got the "I'm busting a gut" face well and truly worked out. Take a look at how he just looks to be trying soooo hard in
every clip. Including the one where he's doing a slow jog at training. I like him as a player more than I did last year, but I'm still not convinced he's going make it. Good decision.
So you think he has the Nick Stevens thing going on.
But Jack actually tries.
And points to Jack for that ... but Stevens was a better player.
Rhys-Jones didn't look like he was trying at all, (except perhaps if he was lining someone up), but his contribution to the team was enormous.
I'm not anti-Jack, but just trying alone does not warrant selection ahead of a player who will ultimately contribute more to the team*.
* and that's meant as a general point rather than a confident statement about Murphy.