aboynamedsue wrote:
Sidefx wrote:
I'm not happy about the result but I am more perplexed how some think this was a winnable game. Yes, they were below us on the ladder, but they have flogged us the last 4 odd years. Plus they have a team full of tall big bodied players and we brought a team of kids, lack of experienced leaders and with 2 unconditioned players to a physical game. It never was going to be a win, but I hoped it wouldn't be the flogging it was.
This!
We won 2 games last year. Two. We have the most under 22s of any side in the comp, then we lose about 600 games experience in one whack. We replace them with our 2nd string ruckman, 2 guys not ready to play AFL (for different reasons) and a talented but sadly out of form forward. And people are saying it was a “winnable game”? Against a side who beat us by 15 goals last time we played them? And who we’ve beaten twice in 10 years? Riiiiiight.
And this is not making excuses or letting anyone off the hook. It’s where we are at. I am not happy about it, I hate losing, but it shits me a bit how some posters go overboard after a good performance and even more overboard after a bad performance. It’s never as good as it seems, it’s never as bad as it seems.
And while I’m at it - “winnable game”.....what the @#$%&! does that even mean? Aren’t they all supposed to be winnable?
I enjoy reading your posts but I reckon your making excuses
I’ll keep banging on about this
SOS has recruited too many average players from other clubs particularly
From GWS
North did their homework on Cripps
Put a star on him
Cripps is a star
He is asked to do too much every week
He got taken out of the game
Game over
A team shouldn’t rely on one player so much
We in all sorts when Newman and Simpson were out
It’s not the 300 game experience
He and Newman are the only ones that move the ball quickly
Out of defence
It’s paramount to move the ball quickly
Plowman Marchbank don’t
Cunningham is one of the few that can move the ball quickly but he was missing as usual
Kreuzers body seems as brittle as a warm chicken bone but
Phillips and Lobbe more did SOS recruits from other clubs expose a lack of physical presence
I’m also starting to have my doubts about Dow and O’Brien
They need to step up a bit
Murphy won’t do that
He has been gone for a while but the club give him 2 years
It’s not an over reaction
If the Pies are on it has the potential to be a massacre
We are mile of it
You have said you think the recruitment under SOS has been ok
I disagree