TalkingCarlton :: View topic - R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)

Sydney Blue wrote:

99prelim wrote:

Sydney Blue wrote:

Brisbane are progressing forward with their development we are going backwards
Sure injuries might have had some impact but they would have still beaten us
we can't sit there are say we lost because player x y and z weren't playing when the last time they were playing we were beaten badly again
A healthy list is a good thing and it helps but when the coaching and development is crap on top of it

Danny might have been a little bit cheeky but he is correct
We can't just keep churning players and hope magically all will fall into place
Carltons problem is and I have been saying it for a while is that it doesn't matter if we win - Winning doesn't count we have been sprouting that message for years
So Development stall - attitudes change and excuses are made
People were moaning that we didin't have a bloke in the side who had 4 disposals all clangers the week before

It is not about personnel it is how you use them that counts
It also helps if they have a positive mind set - we were half way through the season and all the talk was about what we do with pick 1

BV thought we would win 3-4 games in back half of year -not looking likely now

You repeat something often enough it becomes the truth - We will not be defined by wins and losses
Well hasn't that come home to roost

fancy saying that when everything evolves around wins and losses
Problem with Bolton is when you tell bullshite eventually that bullshite comes back and hits you in the face

You lost me there cause you pull unsubstantiated comments out of your arse

And, thankfully for us, the drivel you keep repeating often enough bares no resemblance to the truth

1 win for the year
I would say my drivel is pretty close to the mark

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

Yes, you can hang your hat on the 1 win...no one on this site is going to argue the fact that this year has been a year from hell.

Your drivel stems from a dissertation length attempt to convince based on nothing more than assertions, inference and blame

Can you explain to me how
1. Buckley was so close to being sacked 9 months ago yet is now sitting 2nd
2. Hardwick in 2016
3. Luke Beveridge went from a genius coach to boiled lollies in the 2 seasons post the grand final
4. Adelaide 2018 vs 2017
5. StKilda's disastrous 2018 when they were supposed to be on a par with Melbourne
6. NM's first half of 2018 when they were touted to be bottom 4. They may well still play finals

Your drivel comes from a linear, unidimensional and mutually exclusive lens

Sometimes, shit happens and its reasons stem from multiple factors acting in a radial, connecting and conditional manner

99prelim wrote:

Sydney Blue wrote:

99prelim wrote:

Sydney Blue wrote:

You lost me there cause you pull unsubstantiated comments out of your arse

And, thankfully for us, the drivel you keep repeating often enough bares no resemblance to the truth

1 win for the year
I would say my drivel is pretty close to the mark

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

1/ changed their structures and game plan
2/ changed their structures and game plan

99prelim wrote:

Sydney Blue wrote:

99prelim wrote:

Sydney Blue wrote:

You lost me there cause you pull unsubstantiated comments out of your arse

And, thankfully for us, the drivel you keep repeating often enough bares no resemblance to the truth

1 win for the year
I would say my drivel is pretty close to the mark

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

1/ changed their structures and game plan
2/ changed their structures and game plan
3/ young team massive hangover
5/ injuries, disenchanted players, disharmony, lack of effort
4/ back to moorabbin :lol:

, high draft picks - bad drafting and development, seems like very limited footballers
5/ very good coaching and players enjoying their time

Hey SB, if we improve next season under Bolton can you go away and not come back? You don't deserve to enjoy the good times after years of such mindless negativity towards this club and so many of its true supporters.

Ps: the fact that you still refuse to accept there is a difference between the internal messaging to the players and the media deflection re wins and losses shows how dedicated you are to bashing Bolton and ignoring logic.

You just make up one excuse after another.
Who cares why they changed their game style. They changed it and flew up the ladder. You also said the tigers could't win the granny, why again.
Going small does mean we changed our game style, just another way to give up the ball to the defenders and let them counter. Guard space and think their skill levels are as deplorable as ours because the coach hasn't got any confidence in his players.
We haven't got mids, we have got injuries.
How about they practice their skill and tackling.
How about the coach the kids and let them play to their strengths.
How about they play players in positions their attributes complement their strengths.
How about the coach and his staff do their jobs and actually get the players mentally and physically ready for an game day.

Maybe our coach just can't adjust or just wasn't ready for the demands and rigors of a senior coaching position.
I hope i'm wrong but we will find out soon.

redback wrote:

Well, that settles it then. How stupid is Bolton. The fix is simple.
Play Murphy midfield. Thats his strength. Daisy wing/half forward. Jed Lamb plays best as a defensive forward.
Matty Wright and SPS forward/mids. Jack forward and seems to be showing signs as midfield relief.
Let's just play the specialist backmen in the backline.
Docherty, Williamson, Alex Silvagni, Plowman, Macreadie, Simpson, Byrne. Why not try a couple of the young defenders, JGM, Shumacher?
Why didn't Bolton play any of them last week? You're on fire this week. :lol:

Are you so determined to kick the club that you cant even think through your posts rationally anymore before posting?

Crippa wrote:

what if we don't improve next season? what if it's more of the same, or even worse? what if due to more of the same on field success, Cripps doesn't re-sign with cfc? and other players follow suit and want out like the long list behind them who have already gotten out? it's all plausible right now, yeah?

What if sydney is right? what then?

you talk about flawed logic, crippa ... flawed logic is supporting the current rookie coach for no other reason than the club has had too many coaches lately, and we should stick with one for better or for worse.

I think everyone needs a breather right now, honestly.

I don't know why you guys get so defensive.
You know the outcome but you forget the dynamics.

redback wrote:

I don't know why you guys get so defensive.
You know the outcome but you forget the dynamics.

I'm not getting defensive one bit

I'm just highlighting the fact that yes, like you, my blood boils with rage when I watch Carlton and yes, I get pissed off at selections, game style, poor skills etc.
BUT
Sometimes shit really does happen and I gave you 6 examples that the football world would not have predicted. Your response suggested it was so easy to fix the problems up. It's NOT that easy redback!

I've said before that I am more than comfortable to write off this disaster of a year, see what SOS brings us in November and then accept no excuses for next year. I want to see 8 wins minimum next year and finals in 2020
We will know by round 7 whether BB is there or not in 2020

99prelim wrote:

redback wrote:

I don't know why you guys get so defensive.
You know the outcome but you forget the dynamics.

Fair enough 99.
Just for the record 99 I have never called for his head just for some positives to take into next year or some improvement in areas it's the coach's responsibility to improve and grow the players.

Braithy wrote:

Crippa wrote:

Certainly possible. No guarantees. I agree with the flawed logic part too. That's not a reason to stick with Bolts. Not so sure there is a "long list" of players who wanted out. Hendo maybe. Most others wanted to stay but we didn't want them or we wouldn't offer them enough money or contract length.

If Sydney is right and things don't improve next season or we get even worse, etc. then we will all say "Sydney was right" and we will continue to positively support the club and each other.......and Sydney will say "I was right" plus a massive bunch of negative aggressive stuff towards the club and some of its supporters. That's what.

Crippa wrote:

Braithy wrote:

Crippa wrote:

I am never aggressive towards any supporter.
I only ever have a go at a poster if they have a go at me first.
99% of the stuff that posters say about me I ignore.
If Bolton gets it right I will be the first to admit I was wrong.
I have no issue with that.

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

Author:	redback [ Wed Jul 11, 2018 12:53 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)
99prelim wrote: Sydney Blue wrote: 99prelim wrote: Sydney Blue wrote: Brisbane are progressing forward with their development we are going backwards Sure injuries might have had some impact but they would have still beaten us we can't sit there are say we lost because player x y and z weren't playing when the last time they were playing we were beaten badly again A healthy list is a good thing and it helps but when the coaching and development is crap on top of it Danny might have been a little bit cheeky but he is correct We can't just keep churning players and hope magically all will fall into place Carltons problem is and I have been saying it for a while is that it doesn't matter if we win - Winning doesn't count we have been sprouting that message for years So Development stall - attitudes change and excuses are made People were moaning that we didin't have a bloke in the side who had 4 disposals all clangers the week before It is not about personnel it is how you use them that counts It also helps if they have a positive mind set - we were half way through the season and all the talk was about what we do with pick 1 BV thought we would win 3-4 games in back half of year -not looking likely now You repeat something often enough it becomes the truth - We will not be defined by wins and losses Well hasn't that come home to roost fancy saying that when everything evolves around wins and losses Problem with Bolton is when you tell bullshite eventually that bullshite comes back and hits you in the face You lost me there cause you pull unsubstantiated comments out of your arse And, thankfully for us, the drivel you keep repeating often enough bares no resemblance to the truth 1 win for the year I would say my drivel is pretty close to the mark Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk Yes, you can hang your hat on the 1 win...no one on this site is going to argue the fact that this year has been a year from hell. Your drivel stems from a dissertation length attempt to convince based on nothing more than assertions, inference and blame Can you explain to me how 1. Buckley was so close to being sacked 9 months ago yet is now sitting 2nd 2. Hardwick in 2016 3. Luke Beveridge went from a genius coach to boiled lollies in the 2 seasons post the grand final 4. Adelaide 2018 vs 2017 5. StKilda's disastrous 2018 when they were supposed to be on a par with Melbourne 6. NM's first half of 2018 when they were touted to be bottom 4. They may well still play finals Your drivel comes from a linear, unidimensional and mutually exclusive lens Sometimes, shit happens and its reasons stem from multiple factors acting in a radial, connecting and conditional manner 1/ changed their structures and game plan 2/ changed their structures and game plan 3/ young team massive hangover 5/ injuries, disenchanted players, disharmony, lack of effort 4/ back to moorabbin , high draft picks - bad drafting and development, seems like very limited footballers 5/ very good coaching and players enjoying their time

Author:	Juddy&theKruezers [ Wed Jul 11, 2018 1:27 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)
I remember a lot of people saying before the Essendon* game that if it was our only win for the year they’d be ok with that as long as we beat them ... so the majority of us should be pleased right now ... seriously though ... our major deficiency is belief ... that is a lack of it ... on all levels within the club ... it’ll come though ...

Author:	Blue Vain [ Wed Jul 11, 2018 3:20 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)
redback wrote: 99prelim wrote: Sydney Blue wrote: 99prelim wrote: Sydney Blue wrote: Brisbane are progressing forward with their development we are going backwards Sure injuries might have had some impact but they would have still beaten us we can't sit there are say we lost because player x y and z weren't playing when the last time they were playing we were beaten badly again A healthy list is a good thing and it helps but when the coaching and development is crap on top of it Danny might have been a little bit cheeky but he is correct We can't just keep churning players and hope magically all will fall into place Carltons problem is and I have been saying it for a while is that it doesn't matter if we win - Winning doesn't count we have been sprouting that message for years So Development stall - attitudes change and excuses are made People were moaning that we didin't have a bloke in the side who had 4 disposals all clangers the week before It is not about personnel it is how you use them that counts It also helps if they have a positive mind set - we were half way through the season and all the talk was about what we do with pick 1 BV thought we would win 3-4 games in back half of year -not looking likely now You repeat something often enough it becomes the truth - We will not be defined by wins and losses Well hasn't that come home to roost fancy saying that when everything evolves around wins and losses Problem with Bolton is when you tell bullshite eventually that bullshite comes back and hits you in the face You lost me there cause you pull unsubstantiated comments out of your arse And, thankfully for us, the drivel you keep repeating often enough bares no resemblance to the truth 1 win for the year I would say my drivel is pretty close to the mark Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk Yes, you can hang your hat on the 1 win...no one on this site is going to argue the fact that this year has been a year from hell. Your drivel stems from a dissertation length attempt to convince based on nothing more than assertions, inference and blame Can you explain to me how 1. Buckley was so close to being sacked 9 months ago yet is now sitting 2nd 2. Hardwick in 2016 3. Luke Beveridge went from a genius coach to boiled lollies in the 2 seasons post the grand final 4. Adelaide 2018 vs 2017 5. StKilda's disastrous 2018 when they were supposed to be on a par with Melbourne 6. NM's first half of 2018 when they were touted to be bottom 4. They may well still play finals Your drivel comes from a linear, unidimensional and mutually exclusive lens Sometimes, shit happens and its reasons stem from multiple factors acting in a radial, connecting and conditional manner 1/ changed their structures and game plan 2/ changed their structures and game plan Changed their structures and gameplay through necessity. They lost tall or static forward options so they've stacked their forward lines with a rotation of midfield types. Move the ball forward by any means possible and isolate your mobile options. It's only possible because both teams have been blessed with injuries to their midfield. As I wrote in another thread, the magpies have had 7 games in total lost this year to their top 7 ranked players from last year! Nearly all midfielders. Richmond a similar run of luck. Look at our midfield options. Cripps and ............. Bolton has tried twice to change up our forward lines with smalls and we've been belted both times. You cant make chocolate cake out of a turd.

Author:	redback [ Wed Jul 11, 2018 3:40 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)
You just make up one excuse after another. Who cares why they changed their game style. They changed it and flew up the ladder. You also said the tigers could't win the granny, why again. Going small does mean we changed our game style, just another way to give up the ball to the defenders and let them counter. Guard space and think their skill levels are as deplorable as ours because the coach hasn't got any confidence in his players. We haven't got mids, we have got injuries. How about they practice their skill and tackling. How about the coach the kids and let them play to their strengths. How about they play players in positions their attributes complement their strengths. How about the coach and his staff do their jobs and actually get the players mentally and physically ready for an game day. Maybe our coach just can't adjust or just wasn't ready for the demands and rigors of a senior coaching position. I hope i'm wrong but we will find out soon.

Author:	99prelim [ Wed Jul 11, 2018 10:27 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)
redback wrote: 99prelim wrote: Sydney Blue wrote: 99prelim wrote: Sydney Blue wrote: Brisbane are progressing forward with their development we are going backwards Sure injuries might have had some impact but they would have still beaten us we can't sit there are say we lost because player x y and z weren't playing when the last time they were playing we were beaten badly again A healthy list is a good thing and it helps but when the coaching and development is crap on top of it Danny might have been a little bit cheeky but he is correct We can't just keep churning players and hope magically all will fall into place Carltons problem is and I have been saying it for a while is that it doesn't matter if we win - Winning doesn't count we have been sprouting that message for years So Development stall - attitudes change and excuses are made People were moaning that we didin't have a bloke in the side who had 4 disposals all clangers the week before It is not about personnel it is how you use them that counts It also helps if they have a positive mind set - we were half way through the season and all the talk was about what we do with pick 1 BV thought we would win 3-4 games in back half of year -not looking likely now You repeat something often enough it becomes the truth - We will not be defined by wins and losses Well hasn't that come home to roost fancy saying that when everything evolves around wins and losses Problem with Bolton is when you tell bullshite eventually that bullshite comes back and hits you in the face You lost me there cause you pull unsubstantiated comments out of your arse And, thankfully for us, the drivel you keep repeating often enough bares no resemblance to the truth 1 win for the year I would say my drivel is pretty close to the mark Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk Yes, you can hang your hat on the 1 win...no one on this site is going to argue the fact that this year has been a year from hell. Your drivel stems from a dissertation length attempt to convince based on nothing more than assertions, inference and blame Can you explain to me how 1. Buckley was so close to being sacked 9 months ago yet is now sitting 2nd 2. Hardwick in 2016 3. Luke Beveridge went from a genius coach to boiled lollies in the 2 seasons post the grand final 4. Adelaide 2018 vs 2017 5. StKilda's disastrous 2018 when they were supposed to be on a par with Melbourne 6. NM's first half of 2018 when they were touted to be bottom 4. They may well still play finals Your drivel comes from a linear, unidimensional and mutually exclusive lens Sometimes, shit happens and its reasons stem from multiple factors acting in a radial, connecting and conditional manner 1/ changed their structures and game plan 2/ changed their structures and game plan 3/ young team massive hangover 5/ injuries, disenchanted players, disharmony, lack of effort 4/ back to moorabbin , high draft picks - bad drafting and development, seems like very limited footballers 5/ very good coaching and players enjoying their time Well there you go...it's so easy. I'm surprised that with your 30 word assessment on how to fix up 6 clubs that we don't have all 18 teams making the top 8 and that we dont have 3 or 4 teams winning the premiership every year. Let's hope nobody from opposition clubs read this blueprint of yours on becoming a successful club

TalkingCarlton http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/

R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion) http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=36256	Page 11 of 11

Author:	redback [ Wed Jul 11, 2018 10:35 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)
I don't know why you guys get so defensive. You know the outcome but you forget the dynamics.

Author:	Donstuie [ Wed Jul 11, 2018 11:15 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)
I think everyone needs a breather right now, honestly.

Author:	Crippa [ Wed Jul 11, 2018 11:39 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)
Hey SB, if we improve next season under Bolton can you go away and not come back? You don't deserve to enjoy the good times after years of such mindless negativity towards this club and so many of its true supporters. Ps: the fact that you still refuse to accept there is a difference between the internal messaging to the players and the media deflection re wins and losses shows how dedicated you are to bashing Bolton and ignoring logic.

Author:	Sydney Blue [ Thu Jul 12, 2018 5:19 am ]
Post subject:	Re: R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)
Crippa wrote: Hey SB, if we improve next season under Bolton can you go away and not come back? You don't deserve to enjoy the good times after years of such mindless negativity towards this club and so many of its true supporters. Ps: the fact that you still refuse to accept there is a difference between the internal messaging to the players and the media deflection re wins and losses shows how dedicated you are to bashing Bolton and ignoring logic. Hey Crippa I was very positive under Ratten Can't see there ever being much improvement under Bolton and his crew And I will never go away Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

Author:	Braithy [ Thu Jul 12, 2018 6:04 am ]
Post subject:	Re: R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)
Crippa wrote: Hey SB, if we improve next season under Bolton can you go away and not come back? You don't deserve to enjoy the good times after years of such mindless negativity towards this club and so many of its true supporters. Ps: the fact that you still refuse to accept there is a difference between the internal messaging to the players and the media deflection re wins and losses shows how dedicated you are to bashing Bolton and ignoring logic. what if we don't improve next season? what if it's more of the same, or even worse? what if due to more of the same on field success, Cripps doesn't re-sign with cfc? and other players follow suit and want out like the long list behind them who have already gotten out? it's all plausible right now, yeah? What if sydney is right? what then? you talk about flawed logic, crippa ... flawed logic is supporting the current rookie coach for no other reason than the club has had too many coaches lately, and we should stick with one for better or for worse.

Author:	Blue Vain [ Thu Jul 12, 2018 7:20 am ]
Post subject:	Re: R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)
redback wrote: You just make up one excuse after another. Who cares why they changed their game style. They changed it and flew up the ladder. You also said the tigers could't win the granny, why again. Going small does mean we changed our game style, just another way to give up the ball to the defenders and let them counter. Guard space and think their skill levels are as deplorable as ours because the coach hasn't got any confidence in his players. We haven't got mids, we have got injuries. How about they practice their skill and tackling. How about the coach the kids and let them play to their strengths. How about they play players in positions their attributes complement their strengths. How about the coach and his staff do their jobs and actually get the players mentally and physically ready for an game day. Maybe our coach just can't adjust or just wasn't ready for the demands and rigors of a senior coaching position. I hope i'm wrong but we will find out soon. Well, that settles it then. How stupid is Bolton. The fix is simple. Play Murphy midfield. Thats his strength. Daisy wing/half forward. Jed Lamb plays best as a defensive forward. Matty Wright and SPS forward/mids. Jack forward and seems to be showing signs as midfield relief. Let's just play the specialist backmen in the backline. Docherty, Williamson, Alex Silvagni, Plowman, Macreadie, Simpson, Byrne. Why not try a couple of the young defenders, JGM, Shumacher? Why didn't Bolton play any of them last week? You're on fire this week. Are you so determined to kick the club that you cant even think through your posts rationally anymore before posting?

Author:	redback [ Thu Jul 12, 2018 7:52 am ]
Post subject:	Re: R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)
Blue Vain wrote: redback wrote: You just make up one excuse after another. Who cares why they changed their game style. They changed it and flew up the ladder. You also said the tigers could't win the granny, why again. Going small does mean we changed our game style, just another way to give up the ball to the defenders and let them counter. Guard space and think their skill levels are as deplorable as ours because the coach hasn't got any confidence in his players. We haven't got mids, we have got injuries. How about they practice their skill and tackling. How about the coach the kids and let them play to their strengths. How about they play players in positions their attributes complement their strengths. How about the coach and his staff do their jobs and actually get the players mentally and physically ready for an game day. Maybe our coach just can't adjust or just wasn't ready for the demands and rigors of a senior coaching position. I hope i'm wrong but we will find out soon. Well, that settles it then. How stupid is Bolton. The fix is simple. Play Murphy midfield. Thats his strength. Daisy wing/half forward. Jed Lamb plays best as a defensive forward. Matty Wright and SPS forward/mids. Jack forward and seems to be showing signs as midfield relief. Let's just play the specialist backmen in the backline. Docherty, Williamson, Alex Silvagni, Plowman, Macreadie, Simpson, Byrne. Why not try a couple of the young defenders, JGM, Shumacher? Why didn't Bolton play any of them last week? You're on fire this week. Are you so determined to kick the club that you cant even think through your posts rationally anymore before posting? Conveniently leaving out the staple of our defenders again (Jones, rowe, weitering, and marchbank) just to pretend you have a point. I’m not kicking the club that I have supported all my life but I will not let you pretend they are doing it fine and everything is hunky dory. Looking forward to the mockbuster? Embarrassing!

Author:	Crippa [ Thu Jul 12, 2018 8:16 am ]
Post subject:	Re: R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)
Braithy wrote: Crippa wrote: Hey SB, if we improve next season under Bolton can you go away and not come back? You don't deserve to enjoy the good times after years of such mindless negativity towards this club and so many of its true supporters. Ps: the fact that you still refuse to accept there is a difference between the internal messaging to the players and the media deflection re wins and losses shows how dedicated you are to bashing Bolton and ignoring logic. what if we don't improve next season? what if it's more of the same, or even worse? what if due to more of the same on field success, Cripps doesn't re-sign with cfc? and other players follow suit and want out like the long list behind them who have already gotten out? it's all plausible right now, yeah? What if sydney is right? what then? you talk about flawed logic, crippa ... flawed logic is supporting the current rookie coach for no other reason than the club has had too many coaches lately, and we should stick with one for better or for worse. Certainly possible. No guarantees. I agree with the flawed logic part too. That's not a reason to stick with Bolts. Not so sure there is a "long list" of players who wanted out. Hendo maybe. Most others wanted to stay but we didn't want them or we wouldn't offer them enough money or contract length. If Sydney is right and things don't improve next season or we get even worse, etc. then we will all say "Sydney was right" and we will continue to positively support the club and each other.......and Sydney will say "I was right" plus a massive bunch of negative aggressive stuff towards the club and some of its supporters. That's what.

Author:	Donstuie [ Thu Jul 12, 2018 8:24 am ]
Post subject:	R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)
Donstuie wrote: I think everyone needs a breather right now, honestly. Clearly too subtle. Everyone NEEDS a breather right now otherwise breathers will be forced.

Page 11 of 11	All times are UTC + 10 hours
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/

Author:	99prelim [ Thu Jul 12, 2018 9:18 am ]
Post subject:	Re: R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)
redback wrote: I don't know why you guys get so defensive. You know the outcome but you forget the dynamics. I'm not getting defensive one bit I'm just highlighting the fact that yes, like you, my blood boils with rage when I watch Carlton and yes, I get pissed off at selections, game style, poor skills etc. BUT Sometimes shit really does happen and I gave you 6 examples that the football world would not have predicted. Your response suggested it was so easy to fix the problems up. It's NOT that easy redback! I've said before that I am more than comfortable to write off this disaster of a year, see what SOS brings us in November and then accept no excuses for next year. I want to see 8 wins minimum next year and finals in 2020 We will know by round 7 whether BB is there or not in 2020

Author:	redback [ Thu Jul 12, 2018 10:07 am ]
Post subject:	Re: R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)
99prelim wrote: redback wrote: I don't know why you guys get so defensive. You know the outcome but you forget the dynamics. I'm not getting defensive one bit I'm just highlighting the fact that yes, like you, my blood boils with rage when I watch Carlton and yes, I get pissed off at selections, game style, poor skills etc. BUT Sometimes shit really does happen and I gave you 6 examples that the football world would not have predicted. Your response suggested it was so easy to fix the problems up. It's NOT that easy redback! I've said before that I am more than comfortable to write off this disaster of a year, see what SOS brings us in November and then accept no excuses for next year. I want to see 8 wins minimum next year and finals in 2020 We will know by round 7 whether BB is there or not in 2020 Fair enough 99. Just for the record 99 I have never called for his head just for some positives to take into next year or some improvement in areas it's the coach's responsibility to improve and grow the players.

Author:	99prelim [ Thu Jul 12, 2018 2:01 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)
redback wrote: 99prelim wrote: redback wrote: I don't know why you guys get so defensive. You know the outcome but you forget the dynamics. I'm not getting defensive one bit I'm just highlighting the fact that yes, like you, my blood boils with rage when I watch Carlton and yes, I get pissed off at selections, game style, poor skills etc. BUT Sometimes shit really does happen and I gave you 6 examples that the football world would not have predicted. Your response suggested it was so easy to fix the problems up. It's NOT that easy redback! I've said before that I am more than comfortable to write off this disaster of a year, see what SOS brings us in November and then accept no excuses for next year. I want to see 8 wins minimum next year and finals in 2020 We will know by round 7 whether BB is there or not in 2020 Fair enough 99. Just for the record 99 I have never called for his head just for some positives to take into next year or some improvement in areas it's the coach's responsibility to improve and grow the players.

Author:	Sydney Blue [ Thu Jul 12, 2018 6:38 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)
Crippa wrote: Braithy wrote: Crippa wrote: Hey SB, if we improve next season under Bolton can you go away and not come back? You don't deserve to enjoy the good times after years of such mindless negativity towards this club and so many of its true supporters. Ps: the fact that you still refuse to accept there is a difference between the internal messaging to the players and the media deflection re wins and losses shows how dedicated you are to bashing Bolton and ignoring logic. what if we don't improve next season? what if it's more of the same, or even worse? what if due to more of the same on field success, Cripps doesn't re-sign with cfc? and other players follow suit and want out like the long list behind them who have already gotten out? it's all plausible right now, yeah? What if sydney is right? what then? you talk about flawed logic, crippa ... flawed logic is supporting the current rookie coach for no other reason than the club has had too many coaches lately, and we should stick with one for better or for worse. Certainly possible. No guarantees. I agree with the flawed logic part too. That's not a reason to stick with Bolts. Not so sure there is a "long list" of players who wanted out. Hendo maybe. Most others wanted to stay but we didn't want them or we wouldn't offer them enough money or contract length. If Sydney is right and things don't improve next season or we get even worse, etc. then we will all say "Sydney was right" and we will continue to positively support the club and each other.......and Sydney will say "I was right" plus a massive bunch of negative aggressive stuff towards the club and some of its supporters. That's what. I am never aggressive towards any supporter. I only ever have a go at a poster if they have a go at me first. 99% of the stuff that posters say about me I ignore. If Bolton gets it right I will be the first to admit I was wrong. I have no issue with that. Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

Author:	Crippa [ Thu Jul 12, 2018 7:18 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)
Sydney Blue wrote: Crippa wrote: Braithy wrote: Crippa wrote: Hey SB, if we improve next season under Bolton can you go away and not come back? You don't deserve to enjoy the good times after years of such mindless negativity towards this club and so many of its true supporters. Ps: the fact that you still refuse to accept there is a difference between the internal messaging to the players and the media deflection re wins and losses shows how dedicated you are to bashing Bolton and ignoring logic. what if we don't improve next season? what if it's more of the same, or even worse? what if due to more of the same on field success, Cripps doesn't re-sign with cfc? and other players follow suit and want out like the long list behind them who have already gotten out? it's all plausible right now, yeah? What if sydney is right? what then? you talk about flawed logic, crippa ... flawed logic is supporting the current rookie coach for no other reason than the club has had too many coaches lately, and we should stick with one for better or for worse. Certainly possible. No guarantees. I agree with the flawed logic part too. That's not a reason to stick with Bolts. Not so sure there is a "long list" of players who wanted out. Hendo maybe. Most others wanted to stay but we didn't want them or we wouldn't offer them enough money or contract length. If Sydney is right and things don't improve next season or we get even worse, etc. then we will all say "Sydney was right" and we will continue to positively support the club and each other.......and Sydney will say "I was right" plus a massive bunch of negative aggressive stuff towards the club and some of its supporters. That's what. I am never aggressive towards any supporter. I only ever have a go at a poster if they have a go at me first. 99% of the stuff that posters say about me I ignore. If Bolton gets it right I will be the first to admit I was wrong. I have no issue with that. Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk Fair enough. Fingers crossed for a better result tomorrow night.

Author:	Donstuie [ Thu Jul 12, 2018 7:29 pm ]
Post subject:	R16: Brisbane v Carlton (post match discussion)
This thread is now done. Time to move on from this shitness.