jim wrote:
Wojee wrote:
Pushing for finals?
After a 2 win season?
Think a little harder on that one rather than basically. After 7 wins, 6 wins as well as leading 7 times in last qtrs too afterv2 years where do you think we should be after 4 years. We should be pushing for finals. We won't be but should be. Anyone should know that. Melbourne were. Roos took over a rebuild with 2 wins, had 10 wins by the 3rd. That's the difference. They had a good coach, we have a shit one.
No one knows the actual reason for anything you mention.
There's a better way to put your argument and it starts with " There's a strong possibility, given the numbers show....bla bla bla"
But you always put your argument with dogmatic delivery. Its quite disturbing jim. I am a fan of everyone having an opinion, but frankly yours is not an opinion: it is dogma according to you.
Who was the coach who got them to 6 wins plus 7 games winning at 3/4 time in 2017?
What do you think he did right to take a team which hit rock bottom, under Malthouse, and to get us heading in the right direction?
I'm interested in your opinion, other than Bolton can't coach, what other reasons may be considered for our shocking season this year? Plenty of anti Carlton scribes have given a list of reasons for the public to consume in their condemnation of our club's performance. I'm curious if you agree with them at all?
There's so many layers of stuff that goes on with human beings that need to be factored/ considered, especially young, undeveloped humans around 18-21 imo, let alone the fact we cut very deep with our trade of experienced players for picks. Whether it was too deep or not depends on how fast the team would get to the top 8, let alone top 4. Was that a good move or not to cut so deep? There's arguments both sides, but no one really has the answer. Not even you. Otherwise everyone would be agreeing with you.