TalkingCarlton
http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/

Kids
http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=33876		 Page 1 of 1
Author:  Siegfried [ Mon Apr 07, 2014 2:45 pm ]
Post subject:  Kids
I posted this last year, thought it is now relevant to have a thread of it's own.

Following is a list of each club's best 5 players 23 and under as at August 2013, with any significant others also listed (someone feel free to update it for now, including the last draft and trades). Makes for depressing reading. Upshot is that all the clubs above, around and immediately below where we finished in 2013 have a bunch of kids who are going to make them improve. We don't. Of that list, maybe ours are better than Melbourne and St Kilda's, although after last year's draft, that may no longer be the case. Note I haven't included GWS and GC in this list. Clubs are listed in ladder order as at when I first posted this in Aug.


Hawthorn

Breust (22)
Gunston (21)
Hill (20)
Savage (22)
Whitecross (23)

Shiels (22)
Duryea (22)
Schoenmakers (22)
Anderson (19)

Sydney

Hannebery (22)
Mitchell (20)
Reid (21)
Rohan (22)
Johnson (21)

Rampe (23)
Lamb (20)
Parker (20)
B Jack (19)

Geelong

Christensen (22)
Motlop (22)
Duncan (22)
Smedts (21)
T Hunt (22)

Vardy (22)
Caddy (20)
Guthrie (20)
Horlin-Smith (20)
Blicavs (22)
Menzel (21)
Murdoch (21)
Schroder (20)
Stringer (22)
Thurlow (19)

Fremantle

Fyfe (21)
Hill (23)
De Boer (23)
Walters (22)
Clarke (23)

Morabito (21)
Neale (20)
C Pearce (22)
Suban (23)
Hannath (22)

Essendon*

Zaharakis (23)
Carlisle (21)
Heppell (21)
Hibberd (23)
Hurley (23)

Daniher (19)
Melksham (21)
Kommer (22)
Pears (23)
Colyer (21)
Dell’Olio (23)

Collingwood

Beams (23)
Sidebottom (22)
Blair (23)
Elliott (20)
Fasolo (21)

Seedsman (21)
Sinclair (21)
Grundy (19)
Keeffe (23)
Kennedy (19)
Mooney (20)
J Thomas (21)
Williams (20)

Richmond

Cotchin (23)
Martin (22)
Rance (23)
Vlastuin (19)
Grimes (22)

Astbury (22)
Batchelor (21)
Conca (20)
Dea (21)
Ellis (20)
Helbig (21)
Vickery (23)

Port

Hartlett (22)
Wingard (20)
Wines (19)
Broadbent (23)
Ebert (23)

Butcher (22)
Hitchcock (23)
Jonas (22)
Mitchell (23)
Moore (22)
Neade (19)
O’Shea (21)
Pittard (22)
Redden (22)
Shaw (19)
Trengove (22)

Carlton

Henderson (23)
Tuohy (23)
McInnes (21)
Bootsma (20)
Yarran (22)

Menzel (18)
Curnow (23)
Lucas (22)
Bell (22)
Graham (19)
Buckley (20)
Cachia (22)
Casboult (23)
Dale (20)
Davies (22)
McCarthy (21)
Mitchell (21)
O’Keeffe (23)
Temay (19)
Watson (21)

North

Ziebell (22)
Atley (20)
Bastinac (22)
Black (22)
Cunnington (22)

Mullett (21)
Daw (22)
Harper (21)
Hine (21)
Jacobs (21)
Macmillan (20)
Wright (23)

West Coast

Darling (21)
Naitanui (23)
Gaff (21)
Shuey (23)
S Selwood (23)

Smith (23)
Brennan (23)
Lycett (20)
Sheppard (22)

Brisbane

Rich (23)
Bewick (23)
Mayes (19)
Redden (22)
Banfield (23)

Cornelius (23)
Golby (21)
Green (20)
Longer (20)
Polec (20)
Rockliff (23)

Adelaide

Sloane (23)
Walker (23)
Talia (21)
Crouch (19)
Jaensch (23)
Petrenko (23)
Wright (23)

Dogs

Dahlhaus (20)
Liberatore (21)
Wallis (20)
Hrovat (19)
Stringer (19)

Cordy (23)
Howard (22)
Hunter (19)
Johannisen (20)
Jones (22)
Macrae (19)
Roughead (22)
Smith (20)
Stevens (22)
Talia (20)
Wood (23)

St Kilda

Steven (23)
Hickey (22)
Lee (22)
Siposs (20)
Roberton (22)

Newnes (21)
Ross (20)
Saad (23)
Simpkin (23)
Stanley (22)
Wright (19)

Melbourne

Viney (19)
Blease (22)
Toumpas (19)
Howe (23)
Trengove (21)

Clisby (23)
Fitzpatrick (22)
Gawn (21)
Jetta (23)
Kent (19)
T McDonald (20)
McKenzie (23)
Strauss (23)
Tapscott (22)
Terlich (23)
Watts (22)
Author:  GWS [ Mon Apr 07, 2014 3:45 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Kids
Henderson
Yarran
Menzel
Tuohy
Buckley

Throw a blanket over the rest and move on.
Author:  peabody [ Mon Apr 07, 2014 4:01 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Kids
On your list who are now cut
Dale
Davies
McCarthy
Mitchell
O’Keeffe

And the following are almost certain to be on the scrap heap at the end of this year
McInnes
Bootsma
Lucas
Bell
Cachia
Temay
Casboult (may get a reprieve only due to our lack of talls)
Watson (ditto)

This year we've added
Cripps
Giles
Holman
Docherty

And the rookies (assuming none are over 23)
Reynolds
Johnson
Sheehan
Byrne

Makes for pretty dire reading.
Author:  Siegfried [ Sun Apr 13, 2014 2:09 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: Kids
Updated as at 13 April 2014. Each team's players 23 and under...best 5 and notable others. I've left out last year's draftees unless they've already played games this year. Haven't included the two new teams. Makes for very ugly reading. Most other clubs have a clutch of great kids coming through, which will keep them up there or allow them to improve (what Geelong has managed to do is nothing short of genius). Our best players are 26+, with precious little coming through. We're going backwards.


Carlton

Yarran (23)
Curnow (23)
Menzel (19)
Buckley (21)
Bell (22)

Bootsma (21)
Cachia (22)
Cripps (19)
Docherty (20)
Graham (19)
Lucas (22)
McInnes (22)
Temay (20)
Watson (21)

Hawthorn

Breust (22)
Gunston (22)
Hill (21)
Whitecross (23)
Duryea (22)

Langford (21)
Shiels (22)
Schoenmakers (23)
Anderson (20)

Geelong

Christensen (22)
Motlop (23)
Duncan (22)
Smedts (21)
T Hunt (23)

Vardy (22)
Caddy (21)
Guthrie (21)
Horlin-Smith (21)
Blicavs (23)
Menzel (22)
Murdoch (22)
Schroder (21)
Stringer (23)
Thurlow (20)
Brown (23)
Burbury (21)
Kersten (21)

Sydney

Hannebery (23)
Mitchell (20)
Reid (22)
Rohan (22)
Johnson (22)

Cunningham (19)
Rampe (23)
Lamb (20)
Parker (21)
B Jack (19)


Fremantle

Fyfe (22)
Hill (23)
Walters (23)
C Pearce (23)
Suban (23)

Morabito (22)
Neale (20)
Hannath (22)

Essendon*

Carlisle (22)
Heppell (21)
Hurley (23)
Daniher (20)
Melksham (22)

Ambrose (22)
Kommer (23)
Gleeson (19)
J Merrett (21)

Collingwood

Sidebottom (23)
Blair (23)
Elliott (21)
Fasolo (21)
Grundy (19)

Adams (20)
Seedsman (22)
Sinclair (22)
Keeffe (23)
Kennedy (20)
Langdon (19)
Mooney (21)
J Thomas (22)
Williams (20)
Witts (21)

Richmond

Martin (22)
Vlastuin (19)
Grimes (22)
Conca (21)
Vickery (23)


Astbury (23)
Batchelor (22)
Ellis (20)
Helbig (22)
Griffiths (22)

Port

Hartlett (23)
Wingard (20)
Wines (19)
Broadbent (23)
Polec (21)

Hombsch (21)
Butcher (22)
Impey (18)
Jonas (23)
Mitchell (23)
Neade (19)
O’Shea (22)
Pittard (23)
Redden (23)
Trengove (23)


North

Ziebell (23)
Atley (21)
Bastinac (22)
Black (23)
Cunnington (22)

McDonald (19)
McKenzie (20)
Mullett (22)
Daw (23)
Harper (21)
Jacobs (22)
Macmillan (22)
Wright (23)

West Coast

Darling (21)
Naitanui (23)
Gaff (21)
Shuey (23)
Brennan (23)

Cripps (21)
Yeo (20)
Sheed (19)
Smith (23)
Lycett (21)
Sheppard (22)

Brisbane

Rich (23)
Mayes (19)
Redden (23)
Banfield (23)
Golby (22)

Taylor (19)
Paparone (19)
Lester (21)
Green (21)

Adelaide

Walker (23)
Talia (22)
Crouch (20)
Smith (22)
Grigg (21)

Johnston (23)
Kerridge (20)
Lynch (23)
Shaw (23)
Brown (21)

Dogs

Dahlhaus (21)
Liberatore (21)
Wallis (21)
Macrae (19)
Hunter (19)

Hrovat (19)
Stringer (19)
Cordy (23)
Howard (23)
Johannisen (21)
Jones (23)
Jong (21))
Roughead (23)
Smith (20)
Stevens (22)
Stringer (19)
Talia (21
Tutt (22))

St Kilda

Steven (23)
Hickey (23)
Lee (23)
Siposs (21)
Roberton (22)

Savage (23)
Bruce (21)
Dunstan (19)
Longer (20)
Newnes (21)
Simpkin (23)
Stanley (23)
Templeton (18)

Melbourne

Viney (20)
Toumpas (20)
Howe (23)
Trengove (22)
Tyson (20)

Blease (23)
Fitzpatrick (22)
Gawn (22)
Kent (20)
Kennedy-Harris (19)
T McDonald (21)
McKenzie (23)
Strauss (23)
Tapscott (22)
Watts (22)
Page 1 of 1 All times are UTC + 10 hours
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/