TalkingCarlton :: View topic - David Buttifant to Carlton (confirmed 18/9)

"David's a world-class performance and fitness adviser . . . doctor of science, a wonderful, wonderful person. I rate him as one of the best in Australia and my information is that he's rated very highly in the world," the Blues coach told 3AW.

"With Justin Cordy leaving us at the end of the year we'll be looking at that prospect."

Synbad already decided he was shit

Megaman wrote:

Synbad already decided he was shit

Corrected

bluechucky wrote:

Megaman wrote:

Synbad already decided he was shit

Corrected

yeah ive heard it all before chucky... if he was very good he wouldnt be allowed to go... if he wants to go and he has a year in his contract... he is unprofessional
my guess is both parties are happy for him to move on.... him and collingwood.

we get him... and they will get someone else we want in 3 years time.....

after all... hes been there 13 years.. and everyones happy for him to move on...
sounds like old technology to me....

there are always people pushing through...

but yes i know.. he is leaving collingwood to come to the professional organisation that is carlton..
we can go to arizona .. etc....

there are no other methods except OLD collingwood methods in existence...

:wink:

Buttifant 100% has walked out on Collingwood. He wasnt pushed out at all

Dont underestimate the effect he will have on our playing group mentally. The Collingwood players absolutely love this bloke..... More than Mick and anyone else. HUUUUUGE loss for the Pies. GREAT GET FOR OUR CLUB

bluechucky wrote:

Megaman wrote:

Synbad already decided he was shit

Corrected

yeah ive heard it all before chucky... if he was very good he wouldnt be allowed to go.

:wink:

Synbad wrote:

bluechucky wrote:

Megaman wrote:

Synbad already decided he was shit

Corrected

To be fair, old Collingwood has proven to be better in 2013 than new Collingwood.

Synbad wrote:

bluechucky wrote:

Megaman wrote:

Synbad already decided he was shit

Corrected

yeah ive heard it all before chucky... if he was very good he wouldnt be allowed to go.

:wink:

Explain that to me.

Explain how you keep someone who doesn't want to be there? Do you tie him to his desk?

Moreso, explain WHY you'd want to keep someone who doesn't want to be there.

why doesnt he wanna be there???... first answer me that and then ill answer your question

because not enough money?
not professional enough club?

hes been there 13 years and has one more year on his contract... if he wants to break it because he does nt want to be there... he is unprofessional??
I would assume thats why he signed the contract? In good faith and goodwill to each other?Also for legal reasons.
he is out because he isnt part of the new collingwood ... theyre going to restructure.
We have all the imagination of a pea

Synbad wrote:

We can't play that game forever......... :smile:

Someone moves to club X and it's a coup.
Someone comes to Carlton and it's because no-one else wants him anyway.

Reckon Collingwood would have liked for Mick to be at the helm on Saturday night. No?

bluechucky wrote:

Synbad wrote:

bluechucky wrote:

Megaman wrote:

Synbad already decided he was shit

Corrected

yeah ive heard it all before chucky... if he was very good he wouldnt be allowed to go.

:wink:

Explain that to me.

Explain how you keep someone who doesn't want to be there? Do you tie him to his desk?

Moreso, explain WHY you'd want to keep someone who doesn't want to be there.

Author:	camel [ Mon Sep 09, 2013 11:10 am ]
Post subject:	David Buttifant to Carlton (confirmed 18/9)
So should we just expect his appointment to Carlton to be a formality and if so, should we be happy about it? http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/m ... 2tevm.html Quote: "David's a world-class performance and fitness adviser . . . doctor of science, a wonderful, wonderful person. I rate him as one of the best in Australia and my information is that he's rated very highly in the world," the Blues coach told 3AW. "With Justin Cordy leaving us at the end of the year we'll be looking at that prospect."

Author:	TwinOne [ Mon Sep 09, 2013 2:04 pm ]
Post subject:	David Buttifant to Carlton?
As long as its not Stephen Dank, I'm ok with it.

Author:	Mosquito Fleet [ Mon Sep 09, 2013 2:05 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: David Buttifant to Carlton?
Make it happen....

Author:	Dominator_7 [ Mon Sep 09, 2013 2:12 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: David Buttifant to Carlton?
As if its not a done deal. Cant be announced until our season is over.

Author:	Megaman [ Mon Sep 09, 2013 2:12 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: David Buttifant to Carlton?
We already decided he was shit

TalkingCarlton http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/

David Buttifant to Carlton (confirmed 18/9) http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=33374	Page 1 of 8

Author:	bluechucky [ Mon Sep 09, 2013 2:39 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: David Buttifant to Carlton?
Megaman wrote: Synbad already decided he was shit Corrected

Author:	Synbad [ Mon Sep 09, 2013 4:05 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: David Buttifant to Carlton?
bluechucky wrote: Megaman wrote: Synbad already decided he was shit Corrected yeah ive heard it all before chucky... if he was very good he wouldnt be allowed to go... if he wants to go and he has a year in his contract... he is unprofessional my guess is both parties are happy for him to move on.... him and collingwood. we get him... and they will get someone else we want in 3 years time..... after all... hes been there 13 years.. and everyones happy for him to move on... sounds like old technology to me.... there are always people pushing through... but yes i know.. he is leaving collingwood to come to the professional organisation that is carlton.. we can go to arizona .. etc.... there are no other methods except OLD collingwood methods in existence...

Author:	Warby [ Mon Sep 09, 2013 4:19 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: David Buttifant to Carlton?
Greg Swann was on KB's show this AM; and he was asked whether Buttifant was coming to Carlton. Swanny said....''first I've heard of it....dunno''.................

Author:	camel [ Mon Sep 09, 2013 6:21 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: David Buttifant to Carlton?
Synbad wrote: bluechucky wrote: Megaman wrote: Synbad already decided he was shit Corrected yeah ive heard it all before chucky... if he was very good he wouldnt be allowed to go... if he wants to go and he has a year in his contract... he is unprofessional my guess is both parties are happy for him to move on.... him and collingwood. we get him... and they will get someone else we want in 3 years time..... after all... hes been there 13 years.. and everyones happy for him to move on... sounds like old technology to me.... there are always people pushing through... but yes i know.. he is leaving collingwood to come to the professional organisation that is carlton.. we can go to arizona .. etc.... there are no other methods except OLD collingwood methods in existence... To be fair, old Collingwood has proven to be better in 2013 than new Collingwood.

Author:	trublu [ Mon Sep 09, 2013 6:28 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: David Buttifant to Carlton?
Buttifant 100% has walked out on Collingwood. He wasnt pushed out at all Dont underestimate the effect he will have on our playing group mentally. The Collingwood players absolutely love this bloke..... More than Mick and anyone else. HUUUUUGE loss for the Pies. GREAT GET FOR OUR CLUB

Author:	Trigger [ Mon Sep 09, 2013 6:46 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: David Buttifant to Carlton?
He has probably had enough of kick it to bucks, Walsh obviously had and by the sound of it the players have.

Author:	cimm1979 [ Mon Sep 09, 2013 6:50 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: David Buttifant to Carlton?
trublu wrote: Buttifant 100% has walked out on Collingwood. He wasnt pushed out at all Dont underestimate the effect he will have on our playing group mentally. The Collingwood players absolutely love this bloke..... More than Mick and anyone else. HUUUUUGE loss for the Pies. GREAT GET FOR OUR CLUB Thanks Christie.

Author:	bluechucky [ Mon Sep 09, 2013 8:32 pm ]
Post subject:	David Buttifant to Carlton?
Synbad wrote: bluechucky wrote: Megaman wrote: Synbad already decided he was shit Corrected yeah ive heard it all before chucky... if he was very good he wouldnt be allowed to go. Explain that to me. Explain how you keep someone who doesn't want to be there? Do you tie him to his desk? Moreso, explain WHY you'd want to keep someone who doesn't want to be there.

Author:	Bomba Sheldon [ Mon Sep 09, 2013 8:40 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: David Buttifant to Carlton?
Shock horror, we are chasing someone at Collingwood...............

Page 1 of 8	All times are UTC + 10 hours
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/

Author:	Bigredisback [ Mon Sep 09, 2013 9:05 pm ]
Post subject:	David Buttifant to Carlton?
Whatever mick wants do it

Author:	Synbad [ Mon Sep 09, 2013 9:06 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: David Buttifant to Carlton?
camelboy wrote: Synbad wrote: bluechucky wrote: Megaman wrote: Synbad already decided he was shit Corrected yeah ive heard it all before chucky... if he was very good he wouldnt be allowed to go... if he wants to go and he has a year in his contract... he is unprofessional my guess is both parties are happy for him to move on.... him and collingwood. we get him... and they will get someone else we want in 3 years time..... after all... hes been there 13 years.. and everyones happy for him to move on... sounds like old technology to me.... there are always people pushing through... but yes i know.. he is leaving collingwood to come to the professional organisation that is carlton.. we can go to arizona .. etc.... there are no other methods except OLD collingwood methods in existence... To be fair, old Collingwood has proven to be better in 2013 than new Collingwood. he is old collingwood and collingwood 2013.... the world is constanty changing and you need new ideas... My problem with all this is were only sourcing 'old' collingwood people Swann/Richardson/Brown/Barham/Malthouse/Buttifant.. To me that just shows complete lack of imagination... He didnt walk out on Collingwood... hes part of the culture change... because theyre treading water...

Author:	Synbad [ Mon Sep 09, 2013 9:09 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: David Buttifant to Carlton?
bluechucky wrote: Synbad wrote: bluechucky wrote: Megaman wrote: Synbad already decided he was shit Corrected yeah ive heard it all before chucky... if he was very good he wouldnt be allowed to go. Explain that to me. Explain how you keep someone who doesn't want to be there? Do you tie him to his desk? Moreso, explain WHY you'd want to keep someone who doesn't want to be there. why doesnt he wanna be there???... first answer me that and then ill answer your question because not enough money? not professional enough club? hes been there 13 years and has one more year on his contract... if he wants to break it because he does nt want to be there... he is unprofessional?? I would assume thats why he signed the contract? In good faith and goodwill to each other?Also for legal reasons. he is out because he isnt part of the new collingwood ... theyre going to restructure. We have all the imagination of a pea

Author:	harker [ Mon Sep 09, 2013 9:15 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: David Buttifant to Carlton?
Synbad wrote: why doesnt he wanna be there???... first answer me that and then ill answer your question because not enough money? not professional enough club? hes been there 13 years and has one more year on his contract... if he wants to break it because he does nt want to be there... he is unprofessional?? I would assume thats why he signed the contract? In good faith and goodwill to each other?Also for legal reasons. he is out because he isnt part of the new collingwood ... theyre going to restructure. We have all the imagination of a pea We can't play that game forever......... Someone moves to club X and it's a coup. Someone comes to Carlton and it's because no-one else wants him anyway. Reckon Collingwood would have liked for Mick to be at the helm on Saturday night. No?

Author:	Synbad [ Mon Sep 09, 2013 9:29 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: David Buttifant to Carlton?
harker wrote: Synbad wrote: why doesnt he wanna be there???... first answer me that and then ill answer your question because not enough money? not professional enough club? hes been there 13 years and has one more year on his contract... if he wants to break it because he does nt want to be there... he is unprofessional?? I would assume thats why he signed the contract? In good faith and goodwill to each other?Also for legal reasons. he is out because he isnt part of the new collingwood ... theyre going to restructure. We have all the imagination of a pea We can't play that game forever......... Someone moves to club X and it's a coup. Someone comes to Carlton and it's because no-one else wants him anyway. Reckon Collingwood would have liked for Mick to be at the helm on Saturday night. No? We cant play that game forever( copy collingwood).. whether they wanted him on the helm or not isnt the point.. The point is its not 2000 when Buttifant took over.. its 2013 They have been disappointing and theyre having a clear out. Theyre not looking at Geelong to Xerox... The point is were doing the Xerox of Collingwood .. lock stock and barrel. We are after Daisy.. we were after Cloke last year....Also after O'Bree but couldnt afford him.. You dont see anything weird about all this?... along with everybody we have smuggled. Thats a whole lot of reliance from one source....its extremely unhealthy... Its a plagarism... which means were very unimaginative... Apart from MM they havent felt pain in any other area but coaching. Swann was no biggie Richardson was no biggie development Barham was no biggie in membership Didnt crash and burn because of Brown and they have lost a mass of coaches .... (all working under mm).. oh and we have made a play for their recruiter 3 years ago

Author:	Adam Chatfield [ Mon Sep 09, 2013 9:31 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: David Buttifant to Carlton?
Synbad wrote: bluechucky wrote: Synbad wrote: bluechucky wrote: Megaman wrote: Synbad already decided he was shit Corrected yeah ive heard it all before chucky... if he was very good he wouldnt be allowed to go. Explain that to me. Explain how you keep someone who doesn't want to be there? Do you tie him to his desk? Moreso, explain WHY you'd want to keep someone who doesn't want to be there. why doesnt he wanna be there???... first answer me that and then ill answer your question because not enough money? not professional enough club? hes been there 13 years and has one more year on his contract... if he wants to break it because he does nt want to be there... he is unprofessional?? I would assume thats why he signed the contract? In good faith and goodwill to each other?Also for legal reasons. he is out because he isnt part of the new collingwood ... theyre going to restructure. We have all the imagination of a pea I largely agree our club has issues, but I can't see this as a bad appointment. Bucks wants his own people, it's not a reflection on the ones going out.