Nah, Jim would've laughed. And possibly even yelled "Tell him he's only out there 'cause his old man could play a bit"...which is true. Dylan has a very long way to go. And best case scenario had he not been father-son would probably be a rookie list on the other side of the country.

As always, nice reporting Harker...I hope to get along in February. My reports will be few and far between this year, and they won't be sugar coated. The Carlton Football Club's very small window of opportunity has opened. If they (players, coaches, board) don't take advantage of it, like the Saints and Bulldogs have failed to do, then the club faces a whole new set of problems...that I dare say - knowing this club - they are ill prepared for.

Just telling it like it is Dane. If you find you don't like them, use the foe function!

i think calling it how YOU see it is more accurate.

I think you'll find I'm pretty accurate. But feel free to keep the blindfold on.

i think calling it how YOU see it is more accurate.

why would anyone use the foe function?
oh noes someone on an internet forum offended me! better foe them! i'm too precious to read their posts anymore!

I agree with the comments about Doc. My problem with his observations is his negativity post the SOC incident.

Well I think there's an easy compromise folks. I'll post all the positive, sugar coated, feel-good, kumbaya Carlton stuff on here (in accordance with Dane's wishes). And for anything slightly negative or any criticism or questioning leveled at the club, I can post on SCE (where only a handful will read it anyway).

While a few of you don't like to hear the club publicly being criticized through online forums, the tiny ripple emanating from these forums doesn't rock the boat very much (if at all). The club doesn't care about you. You are irrelevant.

Well I think there's an easy compromise folks. I'll post all the positive, sugar coated, feel-good, kumbaya Carlton stuff on here (in accordance with Dane's wishes). And for anything slightly negative or any criticism or questioning leveled at the club, I can post on SCE (where only a handful will read it anyway).

While a few of you don't like to hear the club publicly being criticized through online forums, the tiny ripple emanating from these forums doesn't rock the boat very much (if at all). The club doesn't care about you. You are irrelevant.