TalkingCarlton :: View topic - R19: Norf game

Simpson and Wells from the same draft. Good to see where both have ended up.

Great game by Simmo tonight.

Pros:

4 Points
Henderson
Slimmo - 4 quarter fantastic effort
Scotland was quality again
Winning Ugly
Warnock - beat the in form ruckman in the comp
Reject backmen - Duigan and Laidler
Kruz worked into it well
Watching Lachie Hansen run around and realising Norf could have taken Selwood, Frawley, Riewoldt, or the Brown twins instead. Hilarious.
1st in with the pro/con post :grin:

Cons:

Goalkicking
Random no name spud # 1437 has a good game against us again (Pedersen this week)
Big Carlton component of the crowd puts money in Norf's coffers. Just die.
#33 and #14. Thanks for your efforts.
Warnock - no confidence in front of goal
Robbo looked tired
#7 coverage. Another 5 years of this shit? Swallow is like a self saucing pudding? That makes even less sense than usual Cometti you hack

Pros:
Beating the vilest of scum NORF.
Hendo
Duigan
Yaz
Gibbs

Cons:
Norf supporters sitting near me with the following remarks:

"HARVEY is a GUN. SO much better then Judd"
"Judd never gets a hard ball"
"Judd's a seagull"
"HE IS SHIT, OK!!!! *proceeds to cry for 8-10 hours*"

Goal Kicking
Norf supporters

Heavs wrote:

I'm not sure Warnock did beat him. Without seeing the stats on hitouts, I'd say Warnock had an ordinary night. Even if he dod get more of them, which I doubt, I can only think of one that went straight to one of our players (Judd) Compare that with his clangers. He did put in a great shepherd for Yarran on the full back line that resulted in a goal and he did give Eddie a great handball that resulted in a Gibbs goal.
Kreuzer had an ordinary night. He is still trying to find his feet. That's OK, because he is so important but let's take off the rose coloured glasses and asses his game objectively.

I agree more with Taff tonight FWIW.

Juzzy wrote:

Why is this a con?

Harvey's results against Judd's speak for themselves.
0 Brownlows
0 premierships
0 Norm Smiths

Hang on....

Bagging McLean (give him a couple of games in a row, Curnow needs to find some form anyways)

Simpson and Wells from the same draft. Good to see where both have ended up.

Great game by Simmo tonight.

Author:	Heavs [ Fri Jul 29, 2011 10:10 pm ]
Post subject:	R19: Norf game - Pros & Cons
Pros: 4 Points Henderson Slimmo - 4 quarter fantastic effort Scotland was quality again Winning Ugly Warnock - beat the in form ruckman in the comp Reject backmen - Duigan and Laidler Kruz worked into it well Watching Lachie Hansen run around and realising Norf could have taken Selwood, Frawley, Riewoldt, or the Brown twins instead. Hilarious. 1st in with the pro/con post Cons: Goalkicking Random no name spud # 1437 has a good game against us again (Pedersen this week) Big Carlton component of the crowd puts money in Norf's coffers. Just die. #33 and #14. Thanks for your efforts. Warnock - no confidence in front of goal Robbo looked tired #7 coverage. Another 5 years of this shit? Swallow is like a self saucing pudding? That makes even less sense than usual Cometti you hack

Author:	grrofunger [ Fri Jul 29, 2011 10:16 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Norf game - Pros & Cons
#1 to #2 hey?

Author:	Heavs [ Fri Jul 29, 2011 10:18 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Norf game - Pros & Cons
grrofunger wrote: #1 to #2 hey? Zach Toovey Zach Toomey

Author:	Sin City [ Fri Jul 29, 2011 10:23 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Norf game - Pros & Cons
Pros Duigan's mark. They weren't gonna lose after that! Simpson, just brilliant. Scotland. Gibbs, quality player in the forward line. Laidler's efforts. Yarran's running game. 8 day break. Improved game from Ellard. Henderson's work on Petrie. Armfield's game on Wells. Cons Terrible kicking at goal Too many missed tackle across the board. Armfield's injury.

Author:	club29 [ Fri Jul 29, 2011 10:25 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R19: Norf game - Pros & Cons
Simpson and Wells from the same draft. Good to see where both have ended up. Great game by Simmo tonight.

TalkingCarlton http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/

R19: Norf game - Pros & Cons http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=30448	Page 1 of 3

Author:	bosman [ Fri Jul 29, 2011 10:34 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R19: Norf game - Pros & Cons
club29 wrote: Simpson and Wells from the same draft. Good to see where both have ended up. Great game by Simmo tonight. Hardly noticed wells tonight... swallow was good...bog Pro got the 4 points in the end. Hendo getting better..... Con did everything possible in the first half to give up top 4...

Author:	Taff [ Fri Jul 29, 2011 10:36 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R19: Norf game - Pros & Cons
Pros Juddy's goal! Duigan's courage Gibb's up forward Heath Scotland Simmo! Hendo's run out of defence. Yazza's runs! We won Cons Bye bye Brock and Houla Warnock's lack of presence and strength on the ball. Woeful kicking for goal in the initial stages of the game. Failure to make a statement at the beginning of the game.

Author:	dane [ Fri Jul 29, 2011 10:54 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R19: Norf game - Pros & Cons
Pros GIBBS - star Murphy - played well again Scotland - mr consistent Hendo - has been great since going back Duigan - sensational mark Laidler - great all round game Yarran - (great resurection of his career) Simpson - great game Jeffrey's goal Cons Bagging McLean (give him a couple of games in a row, Curnow needs to find some form anyways) My bagging of Thornton - he is serviceable Over umpiring Goal kicking Houlihan (what is going on?) That umpiring conference after Simmo's kick

Author:	dane [ Fri Jul 29, 2011 10:55 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R19: Norf game - Pros & Cons
MASSIVE CON CHANNEL 7 COMMENTATORS - FUCK-WITS

Author:	Juzzy [ Fri Jul 29, 2011 11:19 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R19: Norf game - Pros & Cons
Pros: Beating the vilest of scum NORF. Hendo Duigan Yaz Gibbs Cons: Norf supporters sitting near me with the following remarks: "HARVEY is a GUN. SO much better then Judd" "Judd never gets a hard ball" "Judd's a seagull" "HE IS SHIT, OK!!!! proceeds to cry for 8-10 hours" Goal Kicking Norf supporters

Author:	Blue Sombrero [ Fri Jul 29, 2011 11:24 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R19: Norf game - Pros & Cons
Heavs wrote: Pros: 4 Points Henderson Slimmo - 4 quarter fantastic effort Scotland was quality again Winning Ugly Warnock - beat the in form ruckman in the comp Reject backmen - Duigan and Laidler Kruz worked into it well Watching Lachie Hansen run around and realising Norf could have taken Selwood, Frawley, Riewoldt, or the Brown twins instead. Hilarious. 1st in with the pro/con post Cons: Goalkicking Random no name spud # 1437 has a good game against us again (Pedersen this week) Big Carlton component of the crowd puts money in Norf's coffers. Just die. #33 and #14. Thanks for your efforts. Warnock - no confidence in front of goal Robbo looked tired #7 coverage. Another 5 years of this shit? Swallow is like a self saucing pudding? That makes even less sense than usual Cometti you hack I'm not sure Warnock did beat him. Without seeing the stats on hitouts, I'd say Warnock had an ordinary night. Even if he dod get more of them, which I doubt, I can only think of one that went straight to one of our players (Judd) Compare that with his clangers. He did put in a great shepherd for Yarran on the full back line that resulted in a goal and he did give Eddie a great handball that resulted in a Gibbs goal. Kreuzer had an ordinary night. He is still trying to find his feet. That's OK, because he is so important but let's take off the rose coloured glasses and asses his game objectively. I agree more with Taff tonight FWIW.

Author:	ryan2000 [ Fri Jul 29, 2011 11:31 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R19: Norf game - Pros & Cons
Pro:- Lost $25 on North to win. Con:- Lost $25 on North to win. Either way......... Shit game. Just terrible. For me, Scotland has been by far and away our most consistant, important and most valuae player this year. As good as Judd is, and Murphy, and Gibbs,........ Scotland has been consistent week in week out....... Consistency is what we need right now......

Author:	Taff [ Fri Jul 29, 2011 11:36 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R19: Norf game - Pros & Cons
Blue Sombrero wrote: Heavs wrote: Pros: 4 Points Henderson Slimmo - 4 quarter fantastic effort Scotland was quality again Winning Ugly Warnock - beat the in form ruckman in the comp Reject backmen - Duigan and Laidler Kruz worked into it well Watching Lachie Hansen run around and realising Norf could have taken Selwood, Frawley, Riewoldt, or the Brown twins instead. Hilarious. 1st in with the pro/con post Cons: Goalkicking Random no name spud # 1437 has a good game against us again (Pedersen this week) Big Carlton component of the crowd puts money in Norf's coffers. Just die. #33 and #14. Thanks for your efforts. Warnock - no confidence in front of goal Robbo looked tired #7 coverage. Another 5 years of this shit? Swallow is like a self saucing pudding? That makes even less sense than usual Cometti you hack I'm not sure Warnock did beat him. Without seeing the stats on hitouts, I'd say Warnock had an ordinary night. Even if he dod get more of them, which I doubt, I can only think of one that went straight to one of our players (Judd) Compare that with his clangers. He did put in a great shepherd for Yarran on the full back line that resulted in a goal and he did give Eddie a great handball that resulted in a Gibbs goal. Kreuzer had an ordinary night. He is still trying to find his feet. That's OK, because he is so important but let's take off the rose coloured glasses and asses his game objectively. I agree more with Taff tonight FWIW.

Author:	Juzzy [ Fri Jul 29, 2011 11:38 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R19: Norf game - Pros & Cons
Blue Sombrero wrote: Juzzy wrote: Pros: Beating the vilest of scum NORF. Hendo Duigan Yaz Gibbs Cons: Norf supporters sitting near me with the following remarks: "HARVEY is a GUN. SO much better then Judd" "Judd never gets a hard ball" "Judd's a seagull" "HE IS SHIT, OK!!!! proceeds to cry for 8-10 hours" Goal Kicking Norf supporters Why is this a con? Harvey's results against Judd's speak for themselves. 0 Brownlows 0 premierships 0 Norm Smiths Hang on.... Did win a premiership, but as a passenger. Con because i had to listen to the muppets.

Author:	The Normal One [ Fri Jul 29, 2011 11:39 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R19: Norf game - Pros & Cons
Lauchie said F U to his doubters. We have found our CHB come finals, brilliant game and growing in confidence every week. Petrie took some great contested marks, not much you can do as a defender against strong hands. Laidler was great. Scotland and Simmo reliable as always. Yarran said Harvey you slow ...... T-Bird was great. The best though was Mr Biggest Turnaround in a season Marcus Davies. Still needs to work on his one grab, but he is making it hard to drop him.

Author:	MIL [ Fri Jul 29, 2011 11:43 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R19: Norf game - Pros & Cons
Pros We won Gibbsy (except THAT poor decision to kick to Eduardo ) Duigan Laidler (a great kick isn't he ?) Thornton (this is the bloke that 98% of us wanted gone, me included ) Judd 2nd half Simmo all night Yazz Hendo, esp when it hits the deck. The bloke has pace and poise Davies (just needs to improve on his efforts when he has time, but did a lot of good instinctive things) Touhy 206 - he ain't perfect but he is well, 206, and Goldie is the no.1 hit out man in the AFL this year Brock The Rock wasn't as bad as I thought, apart from that woeful tackle attempt Waite, Hammer, Jammo, JR and Carrots to come back. Cons By far the worst umpired game I've seen for a long long time. Wonder how many the Geesh will acknowledge ? Army's ankle. Ice, Ice and more Ice.

Page 1 of 3	All times are UTC + 10 hours
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/

Author:	bluedog [ Fri Jul 29, 2011 11:41 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R19: Norf game - Pros & Cons
I reckon Kreuzer's 'ordinary' games are still pretty good. Good presence, makes a contest, scraps it forward when there are no other options.

Author:	QLD_Blue [ Fri Jul 29, 2011 11:44 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R19: Norf game - Pros & Cons
dane wrote: Bagging McLean (give him a couple of games in a row, Curnow needs to find some form anyways)

Author:	kezza [ Fri Jul 29, 2011 11:54 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: R19: Norf game - Pros & Cons
club29 wrote: Simpson and Wells from the same draft. Good to see where both have ended up. Great game by Simmo tonight. I hardly noticed Wells either. Simmo has been a wonderful player, i know who i would rather have.