Andrew Carrazzo. Not our best player, but still a safe best 22 type, probably our equivalent of Andrew Welsh, in that every time he's in the media representing our club, he's a polished media performer and well spoken. Something I can't quite give to young Murph just yet.

Has had quite a good year, has Carrots, improved in a lot of areas that people haven't given him the credit for (become quite a deadly finisher around goals being the main one), and should be rewarded for this, in a year where he could quite easily have been lost in the shuffle.

Andrew Carrazzo. Not our best player, but still a safe best 22 type, probably our equivalent of Andrew Welsh, in that every time he's in the media representing our club, he's a polished media performer and well spoken. Something I can't quite give to young Murph just yet.

Has had quite a good year, has Carrots, improved in a lot of areas that people haven't given him the credit for (become quite a deadly finisher around goals being the main one), and should be rewarded for this, in a year where he could quite easily have been lost in the shuffle.

Good point. I'd be happy with Carrots.

But at the end of the day, like Hornet, Waite has done enough to deserve it imo.

..Murphos by the length of the flemington straight..

..surely you've put the Fevalenko on the poll as a joke right..?..

Murph and Gibbsy dual VC's...

I voted Simmo, but I believe Simmo and Carrots should share duties.

To me they've shown the most leadership at the club.