For some the season will result in a final for others, the season will end in disappointment. I haven't listed the Bannisters etc. who will be delisted.

I need to improve so I can play finals next year
Grigg
Austin
Bower
Browne
Yarran

I did improve
Murphy
Joseph
Russell
Armfield

A bit tough on "Our Bower", he's been great this year.

I think we just have to get used to the fact that he looks like a disaster waiting to happen when he runs the ball. Ungainly he may be, but that side of his game has developed massively in 2009 and should only get better.

_________________
Click here to follow TalkingCarlton on twitter
TalkingCarlton Posting Rules

Woops

Cut and paste can mess you up.

Bower has improved

Bit hard on Yarran, I think. Same could be said for almost any first year player.

Still, good post.

Most disappointed in Grigg. I thought he showed a lot last year in what I have now seen and seems to have dropped off a bit. I hope he rebounds next season. Looking forward to him and Mitch Robinson becoming quality midfielders in our system.

In todays game, first year players really need to step up and deliver

Collingwood and Essendon* seem to get this right.

Yarran has been a major disappointment, we really should have taken Rich.

We need to get it right. We still have plenty of dead wood to remove, so we need 1st year players to be ready to play.

2nd year players can also struggle, so we need to make sure that we improve our depth.

No they don't. First year players come with a 2 year contract and if you're a first round pick you can be nearly guaranteed that you'll score an extension regardless of what you've shown. No club recruits players from underage competitions with the desire to improve their starting team for the next season.

On the one hand I agree with you, while on the other I couldn't disagree more.

Yarran might not have had the impact in 2009 that Rich or some of his other contemporaries have had. But you need to realise we have recruited Yarran for 10+ years of footy, not just one. Besides, after the draft the club always maintained that Yarran would take a couple of years before they expected him to fulfil his potential.

Rather than stepping up and delivering, I think first year players need to show they have promise and talent. Yarran has done that.

Yes, some guys will adapt to AFL much quicker than others. However, give a bloke like Yarran a few years to get those 50-60 games under his belt and he will repay that faith.

Developing footballers and teams is not as simple as flicking a switch. It takes time.

I do agree that I was expecting more from Yarran in 2009, but while he didn't meet my expectations he did show he has promise and talent. He'll come good. It might be a struggle for the impatient types to wait for him to mature, but all things being equal he will make it. Just you wait and see.

_________________
Click here to follow TalkingCarlton on twitter
TalkingCarlton Posting Rules