cj69 wrote:
Fluffy article that skirts around the issues and asks more questions than it answers.
IMO we will not be able to challenge the top sides until we learn to play without Fev.
Fev adds 5 - 6 goals per game to our structure because opposition players in Fev's vicinity start zoning off or sagging the zone a little whenever he is a chance of getting the ball. You just don't get that effect from Cloke, or Wiggins, or Carlos, or Hartlett, or Edwards, or Fisher... The idea of Hampson as a key forward weapon might be a fable as well.
It seems the MC also noticed?
Brett Ratten wrote:
"There were a lot of things – our first half, to have 31 inside 50s to 19 – that's when you've got to grab your opportunities and we didn't convert. They won a lot of one-on-ones in our forward 50 ... there were a lot of other things before that kick.
"It was an outstanding performance to kick 8.4; he did a great job for the team. Other players in the game had a moment they wish they could change."
As we saw from the weekend, we have the players in our side to exploit those gaps in the best sides. Hawthorn knew that we were one man short in cover or 'help' defence (in our best side, I would say Grigg or Walker) and played through big Roughead. Players like Roughead, Fev, Franklin, Brown and Bradshaw are hard to stop on a lead - unless you zone off. If we're going to do that, there has to be a combination of smarts and ability. Thornton was kick chasing on Roughead in the first quarter. He has to be smarter than that because he does not have the ability to close on a big, strong bloke from that distance.
That, IMO, is the precise reason why Cloke is getting a little cold in Yarran's seat. For the best balance and most damaging use of Fevola's ability, when Yarran is ready, we go with the crumbers - who can create from a pack situation or cause a stoppage for our midfield unit to capitalise - and play an extra mobile, defensive tall. The hard part of coaching is knowing when Yarran will be ready - we are still trying to win games, and you don't win if you have to carry blokes that you're counting on for goals.