TalkingCarlton
http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/

2011 Premiership side!
http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=23699		 Page 1 of 1
Author:  cj69 [ Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:37 am ]
Post subject:  2011 Premiership side!
All going well I believe that this year we will get a taste of finals football and in 2010/2011 really challenge for the flag. The question is why? For me it will be imperative to have player who can run and hit targets. The key is to retain possession and attack from defence and also win the ball at the clearances. Plus we need a spread of goalkickers!

So is this the side to do it?

Backs: Johnson Bower Jamison
Gibbs
Anderson Walker O'Keefe

Mids: Waite Hadley Robinson Browne
Hampson Judd Murphy

Forwards: Yarran Austin
Kruezer Garfield

Int: Warnock Armfield Grigg Bentley
Author:  Blue Sombrero [ Sun Jan 11, 2009 6:55 am ]
Post subject:  Re: 2011 Premiership side!
cj69 wrote:
All going well I believe that this year we will get a taste of finals football and in 2010/2011 really challenge for the flag. The question is why? For me it will be imperative to have player who can run and hit targets. The key is to retain possession and attack from defence and also win the ball at the clearances. Plus we need a spread of goalkickers!

So is this the side to do it?

B: Johnson Bower Jamison
HB: Anderson Walker O'Keefe
C: Waite Gibbs Robinson
HF: Yarran Austin Hadley
F: Garfield Kruezer Browne
Foll: Hampson Judd Murphy
Int: Warnock Armfield Grigg Bentley

I doubt it. For starters it implies we won't be trading anybody in or out. 2010-11 is a long way off yet and second guessing the list so far in front is pretty gutsy.
Secondly, It implies Robinson will be better than Grigg, which if that happens will be great but IMO Grigg will be one of our top ten players by then.
Thirdly, where is Fev? He won't go from almost Colemen medallist to the Bullants in 2-3 years
Fourthly, Walker will never play CHB ahead of Waite or even Setanta.
Fifthly, Hadley is not suited to HFF. Simmo would play there before him and he isn't in your 22.
Nice try, but. Maybe this time next year your task will be easier.
Whilst I am happy to criticise, I haven't got the guts to try and do better :oops:
Author:  cj69 [ Sun Jan 11, 2009 9:46 am ]
Post subject:  Re: 2011 Premiership side!
Blue Sombrero wrote:
cj69 wrote:
All going well I believe that this year we will get a taste of finals football and in 2010/2011 really challenge for the flag. The question is why? For me it will be imperative to have player who can run and hit targets. The key is to retain possession and attack from defence and also win the ball at the clearances. Plus we need a spread of goalkickers!

So is this the side to do it?

B: Johnson Bower Jamison
HB: Anderson Walker O'Keefe
C: Waite Gibbs Robinson
HF: Yarran Austin Hadley
F: Garfield Kruezer Browne
Foll: Hampson Judd Murphy
Int: Warnock Armfield Grigg Bentley

I doubt it. For starters it implies we won't be trading anybody in or out. 2010-11 is a long way off yet and second guessing the list so far in front is pretty gutsy.
Secondly, It implies Robinson will be better than Grigg, which if that happens will be great but IMO Grigg will be one of our top ten players by then.
Thirdly, where is Fev? He won't go from almost Colemen medallist to the Bullants in 2-3 years
Fourthly, Walker will never play CHB ahead of Waite or even Setanta.
Fifthly, Hadley is not suited to HFF. Simmo would play there before him and he isn't in your 22.
Nice try, but. Maybe this time next year your task will be easier.
Whilst I am happy to criticise, I haven't got the guts to try and do better :oops:



Fair points BS but can't agree.

Starting on the bench means nothing. Players rotate and have equal time on the field. Grigg will be part of the midfield rotations.

I don't think Fev will be part of it. Big call I know but he will be around 30 and injuries etc will take their toll on him.

Walker needs to settle in a position to get the best out of him. He is the perfect matchup for a Reiwoldt, Franklin etc and can attack as well.

Hadley has played most of his footy at HF and will be part of the mid rotation. He is a goalkicker as well and can take a mark as well as lock the ball in.

I fear for Simmo, fantastic player but is small and cannot put on muscle. These players generally have shorter careers.

Just my opinions though! :grin:
Author:  Kaptain Kouta [ Sun Jan 11, 2009 9:48 am ]
Post subject:  Re: 2011 Premiership side!
2011?

I don't want to wait until 2011!
Author:  blueboy23 [ Mon Jan 12, 2009 6:11 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: 2011 Premiership side!
not sure if to much will change in 2 years. i think austin will be a regular as will robinson.

maybe?
armfield jamison austin
grigg bower anderson
simpson gibbs stevens
yarran waite walker
betts fevola kreuzer

warnock judd murphy

robinson hampson browne hadley

also carrazzo, o'keefe, gartlett and our future picks plus any trades, but finally we have some depth.
Author:  Kouta [ Mon Jan 12, 2009 6:42 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: 2011 Premiership side!
cj69 wrote:
Backs: Johnson Bower Jamison
Gibbs
Anderson Walker O'Keefe

Mids: Waite Hadley Robinson Browne
Hampson Judd Murphy

Forwards: Yarran Austin
Kruezer Garfield

Int: Warnock Armfield Grigg Bentley

You can't even find room for Thornton and Betts ahead of Bentley, Johnson, Anderson and Garlett? :? :oops:
Author:  Lace Out [ Mon Jan 12, 2009 7:27 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: 2011 Premiership side!
cj69 wrote:
Blue Sombrero wrote:
cj69 wrote:
All going well I believe that this year we will get a taste of finals football and in 2010/2011 really challenge for the flag. The question is why? For me it will be imperative to have player who can run and hit targets. The key is to retain possession and attack from defence and also win the ball at the clearances. Plus we need a spread of goalkickers!

So is this the side to do it?

B: Johnson Bower Jamison
HB: Anderson Walker O'Keefe
C: Waite Gibbs Robinson
HF: Yarran Austin Hadley
F: Garfield Kruezer Browne
Foll: Hampson Judd Murphy
Int: Warnock Armfield Grigg Bentley

I doubt it. For starters it implies we won't be trading anybody in or out. 2010-11 is a long way off yet and second guessing the list so far in front is pretty gutsy.
Secondly, It implies Robinson will be better than Grigg, which if that happens will be great but IMO Grigg will be one of our top ten players by then.
Thirdly, where is Fev? He won't go from almost Colemen medallist to the Bullants in 2-3 years
Fourthly, Walker will never play CHB ahead of Waite or even Setanta.
Fifthly, Hadley is not suited to HFF. Simmo would play there before him and he isn't in your 22.
Nice try, but. Maybe this time next year your task will be easier.
Whilst I am happy to criticise, I haven't got the guts to try and do better :oops:



Fair points BS but can't agree.

Starting on the bench means nothing. Players rotate and have equal time on the field. Grigg will be part of the midfield rotations.

I don't think Fev will be part of it. Big call I know but he will be around 30 and injuries etc will take their toll on him.

Walker needs to settle in a position to get the best out of him. He is the perfect matchup for a Reiwoldt, Franklin etc and can attack as well.

Hadley has played most of his footy at HF and will be part of the mid rotation. He is a goalkicker as well and can take a mark as well as lock the ball in.

I fear for Simmo, fantastic player but is small and cannot put on muscle. These players generally have shorter careers.

Just my opinions though! :grin:


I have to disagree about Fev. If a player like Gherig can play into his 30's, then so can Fev. Infact i think that Fev is one of the best built FF to have played. He may of even been designed and build by Tonka. I still can't believe that his knee didn't give way completely after the way he landed on it against North a couple of seasons ago, the guy is indestructable!

He has a unique build, and a cast Iron jaw and this superhero will play well into his 30's IMHO, unless he loses the desire.....
Author:  cecil89 [ Tue Jan 13, 2009 10:33 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: 2011 Premiership side!
cj69 wrote:
All going well I believe that this year we will get a taste of finals football and in 2010/2011 really challenge for the flag. The question is why? For me it will be imperative to have player who can run and hit targets. The key is to retain possession and attack from defence and also win the ball at the clearances. Plus we need a spread of goalkickers!

So is this the side to do it?

Backs: Johnson Bower Jamison
Gibbs
Anderson Walker O'Keefe

Mids: Waite Hadley Robinson Browne
Hampson Judd Murphy

Forwards: Yarran Austin
Kruezer Garfield

Int: Warnock Armfield Grigg Bentley


Sorry, but without fev, that team doesn't look premiership quality. I'd like to see O'keefe, Robinson & Garlett play before i pencil them into our next premiership team. Eddie Betts is sure to be there as well. And i think we'll win the premiership in 2010.

But if this is the team that wins us a premiership, i'd be stoked. It would indicate that our young players have significantly kicked on.
Author:  Blueboy_Dan [ Wed Jan 14, 2009 2:11 am ]
Post subject:  Re: 2011 Premiership side!
Isnt it funny how supporters overrate their own players and hype up all new recruits even those taken with late picks?

Robinson and Yarran havent even played a game of footy and people are already talking them up as superstars, just settle down.

Oh and even in that bizzare lineup, where the hell is Fev?
Author:  Virgin Blue [ Wed Jan 14, 2009 7:44 am ]
Post subject:  Re: 2011 Premiership side!
don't know about Garfield, but Snoopy is a shoe in
Author:  true_blue3 [ Wed Jan 14, 2009 8:30 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: 2011 Premiership side!
i'll have a crack, even though i know there is a huge chance there could be upto 10 differences.

ages for pre-season 2011 in brackets

FB: thornton (27) jamison (24) anderson (22)

HB: grigg (22) bower (23) browne (22)

C: walker (24) gibbs (21) simpson (26)

HF: yarran (20) waite (28) stevens (31)

FF: betts (24) fevola (30) houlihan (29)

RR: kreuzer (21) judd (27) murphy (23)

INT: hampson (22) carrazzo (27) robinson (20) fisher (26)

EMG: warnock (24) russell (24) o'hailpin (27)

- in green are the guys who should definitely play in our 2011 premiership team pending availabilty

- in red are the guys who i think will be made to really earn their spot in this team (looking back that didn't exactly make much difference....)
Author:  bondiblue [ Thu Jan 15, 2009 6:10 pm ]
Post subject:  Re: 2011 Premiership side!
true_blue3 wrote:
i'll have a crack, even though i know there is a huge chance there could be upto 10 differences.

ages for pre-season 2011 in brackets

FB: thornton (27) jamison (24) anderson (22)

HB: grigg (22) bower (23) browne (22)

C: walker (24) gibbs (21) simpson (26)

HF: yarran (20) waite (28) stevens (31)

FF: betts (24) fevola (30) houlihan (29)

RR: kreuzer (21) judd (27) murphy (23)

INT: hampson (22) carrazzo (27) robinson (20) fisher (26)

EMG: warnock (24) russell (24) o'hailpin (27)

- in green are the guys who should definitely play in our 2011 premiership team pending availabilty

- in red are the guys who i think will be made to really earn their spot in this team (looking back that didn't exactly make much difference....)


Great team tb3...and those emergencies in 2 years will be allright too, let alone a few more imports. Bodes well for a successful era to look forward to.
Author:  blue4 [ Sun Jan 18, 2009 8:51 am ]
Post subject:  Re: 2011 Premiership side!
I have this feeling Kreuzer will only be a part time ruck and full time forward.

I reckon Hampson and Warnock will do most of the ruck this year with Kreuzer chipping in.

Good thing is with these three blokes, in particular Keuzer will be a constant threat to the forward line.

Cloke is a warrior and will hang around but don't see him as a regular but definitely adds to the squad just like Hadley, Houlihan, Russell, Fisher & Wiggins.
Page 1 of 1 All times are UTC + 10 hours
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/