and used his board for my first ever attempt at one of these. Its harder than it looks and I have left out a lot of class and young talent. And I couldnt find a spot for Simmo!!
| TalkingCarlton http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/ |
|
| Our best 22? http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=21390 |
Page 165 of 172 |
| Author: | ianh [ Sun Dec 01, 2019 7:44 am ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Our best 22? |
supercoach wrote: Where has jimae’s team board gone? Can anyone make a similar one up? No need, jimmae has us covered http://jimmae.rf.gd/teamboard.html?i=1 Kudos to the man. |
|
| Author: | Cazzesman [ Sun Dec 01, 2019 9:45 am ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Our best 22? |
B: Newman Jones Plowman HB: Docherty Weitering Simpson C: SPS Cripps Newnes HF:Charlie McKay Martin F: Betts McGovern Fisher R: Kreuzer Walsh Murphy IC: Ed Gibbons Setterfield Casboult E: JSOS Dow Cunners Marchbank Williams Stocker Kennedy O'Brien The thing I am loving is the 8 emergencies I can't squeeze in. Lots of pressure on positions. I could live with JSOS or Cunners for Fisher in the lineup. I think we will get to see the best of what Setterfield and McGovern can bring to the park if they get a full preseason in. Adding Doc (92), Newnes (155), Eddie (316) and Martin (97) certainly increases the skill level and footy experience/smarts. It might not hurt to give Simmo a spell from time to time throughout the year. He is still worth his spot but is he keeping out a fit Stocker, Williams and/or Marchbank. Always exciting this time of the year. No need to rush any 1st year players in until they are performing solidly at VFL level and building their bodies. Regards Cazzesman |
|
| Author: | moshe25 [ Sun Dec 01, 2019 10:56 am ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Our best 22? |
Cazzesman wrote: B: Newman Jones Plowman I love that you managed to squeeze Diesel into the emergencies. Kudos. HB: Docherty Weitering Simpson C: SPS Cripps Newnes HF:Charlie McKay Martin F: Betts McGovern Fisher R: Kreuzer Walsh Murphy IC: Ed Gibbons Setterfield Casboult E: JSOS Dow Cunners Marchbank Williams Stocker Kennedy O'Brien The thing I am loving is the 8 emergencies I can't squeeze in. Lots of pressure on positions. I could live with JSOS or Cunners for Fisher in the lineup. I think we will get to see the best of what Setterfield and McGovern can bring to the park if they get a full preseason in. Adding Doc (92), Newnes (155), Eddie (316) and Martin (97) certainly increases the skill level and footy experience/smarts. It might not hurt to give Simmo a spell from time to time throughout the year. He is still worth his spot but is he keeping out a fit Stocker, Williams and/or Marchbank. Always exciting this time of the year. No need to rush any 1st year players in until they are performing solidly at VFL level and building their bodies. Regards Cazzesman Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk |
|
| Author: | supercoach [ Sun Dec 01, 2019 4:17 pm ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Our best 22? |
ianh wrote: supercoach wrote: Where has jimae’s team board gone? Can anyone make a similar one up? No need, jimmae has us covered http://jimmae.rf.gd/teamboard.html?i=1 Kudos to the man. |
|
| Author: | GMCbris [ Sun Dec 01, 2019 8:10 pm ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Our best 22? |
and used his board for my first ever attempt at one of these. Its harder than it looks and I have left out a lot of class and young talent. And I couldnt find a spot for Simmo!!
|
|
| Author: | aboynamedsue [ Sun Dec 01, 2019 9:33 pm ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Our best 22? |
Newnes ahead of Simmo? Really? |
|
| Author: | GreatEx [ Mon Dec 02, 2019 7:42 am ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Our best 22? |
Can't believe some still don't see Newman in our best 22 |
|
| Author: | Teen Spirit [ Mon Dec 02, 2019 11:39 am ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Our best 22? |
I see our best 22 lining up as follows: Docherty Jones Marchbank Newman Weitering Plowman SPS Murphy Setterfield Martin C.Curnow Fisher McGovern McKay Betts Kreuzer Cripps Walsh Dow, Simpson, E.Curnow, Casboult That leaves our VFL side looking something like this: B.Silvagni Goddard O'Brien Newnes Macreadie Williamson Lang Kennedy Cottrell Cuningham De Koning Ramsay Owies J.Silvagni Polson Pittonet Gibbons Stocker Philp, ODwyer, Honey, Phillips, Kemp Overall we've got solid depth on every line - the fact that guys like Kennedy, Cuningham, Stocker, Silvagni and Gibbons aren't guaranteed walk up starts to our best 22 shows that we've invested really well in our recruiting. It's really important now that we keep them all fit and injury free as development in the VFL has been non-existent in recent years, leading us to play guys at AFL level who weren't ready for that level and they've been fed to the wolves and beaten up from time to time. The most interesting spot in our 22 currently belongs to Casboult - Levi's end of season form was ridiculous, but we're too tall as it is and need to find a solution to our ruck/key fwd mix in 2020. |
|
| Author: | bluechampion [ Mon Dec 02, 2019 4:44 pm ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Our best 22? |
Our OLDEST team: B: Marchbank - Jones - Newman HB: Simpson - Plowman - Docherty C: Murphy - Cripps - Newnes HF: Lang - C. Curnow - Martin F: McGovern - Casboult - Betts R: Kreuzer - E. Curnow - Gibbons INT: Pittonet - Cunningham - Goddard - Owies |
|
| Author: | bluechampion [ Mon Dec 02, 2019 4:56 pm ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Our best 22? |
Our YOUNGEST side: B: Williamson - Weitering - B. Silvagni HB: SPS - Macreadie - O'Brien C: Walsh - Dow - Fisher HF: Honey - McKay - Cottrell FF: Polson - J.Silvagni- O'Dwyer R: De Koning - Stocker - Setterfield INT: Kemp - Phillips - Ramsay - Philp |
|
| Author: | bondiblue [ Mon Dec 02, 2019 8:51 pm ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Our best 22? |
bluechampion wrote: Our YOUNGEST side: B: Williamson - Weitering - B. Silvagni HB: SPS - Macreadie - O'Brien C: Walsh - Dow - Fisher HF: Honey - McKay - Cottrell FF: Polson - J.Silvagni- O'Dwyer R: De Koning - Stocker - Setterfield INT: Kemp - Phillips - Ramsay - Philp Those 2 teams you put up are amazing to evaluate. The oldest team looks better than most teams since and before Judd till way back to 2002. And, it doesn't include Weitering Walsh McKay JSOS Setterfield SPS OBrien ... I feel good. Good night. |
|
| Author: | Big Kahuna Boot [ Sun Dec 08, 2019 1:06 am ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Our best 22? |
..it's becoming genuinely more difficult.. FB: Plowman Jones Newman HB: Marchbank Weitering Docherty C: Walsh E.Curnow Simpson HF: SPS C.Curnow Martin FF: McGovern McKay Betts RR: Kreuzer Cripps Murphy Int: Setterfield Dow Kennedy Fisher |
|
| Author: | bluechampion [ Sat Jan 04, 2020 4:13 pm ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Our best 22? |
Our MOST EXPERIENCED (games played) side: B: Simpson - Jones - Plowman HB: Docherty - Weitering - Newnes C: Murphy - E. Curnow - SPS HF: Lang - C. Curnow - Martin F: Betts - Casboult - McGovern R: Kreuzer - Cripps - J. Silvagni |
|
| Author: | blues_clues [ Mon Jan 06, 2020 1:08 pm ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Our best 22? |
Mckay's groin injury is worse than Joe Danihers which has kept him out of the game for a long time. Harry could miss a majority of 2020 is what i've been told. |
|
| Author: | bondiblue [ Tue Jan 07, 2020 7:03 pm ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Our best 22? |
blues_clues wrote: Mckay's groin injury is worse than Joe Danihers which has kept him out of the game for a long time. Harry could miss a majority of 2020 is what i've been told. That's not good news. May as well add to the bad news ... I heard a surgeon close to op suggests Charlie will take a few months to be fully fit, not 2 months....but at least he will return... Come on down Levi and Gov. Create a contest at the very least and leave the groundwork to the 4 Amigos |
|
| Author: | Blue Sombrero [ Wed Jan 08, 2020 2:16 pm ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Our best 22? |
Cazzesman wrote: B: Newman Jones Plowman HB: Docherty Weitering Simpson C: SPS Cripps Newnes HF:Charlie McKay Martin F: Betts McGovern Fisher R: Kreuzer Walsh Murphy IC: Ed Gibbons Setterfield Casboult E: JSOS Dow Cunners Marchbank Williams Stocker Kennedy O'Brien The thing I am loving is the 8 emergencies I can't squeeze in. Lots of pressure on positions. I could live with JSOS or Cunners for Fisher in the lineup. I think we will get to see the best of what Setterfield and McGovern can bring to the park if they get a full preseason in. Adding Doc (92), Newnes (155), Eddie (316) and Martin (97) certainly increases the skill level and footy experience/smarts. It might not hurt to give Simmo a spell from time to time throughout the year. He is still worth his spot but is he keeping out a fit Stocker, Williams and/or Marchbank. Always exciting this time of the year. No need to rush any 1st year players in until they are performing solidly at VFL level and building their bodies. Regards Cazzesman Gibbons ahead of Jack is interesting for me. Gibbons went well last season in a mostly forward role with time in the midfield. Is he selected as a mid primarily or a forward? I think Jack is more versatile and that's what I like in the I/C. |
|
| Author: | Blue Sombrero [ Thu Feb 27, 2020 11:15 am ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Our best 22? |
OK. I think this is the best team we can put on the park. Yes, I know, Kreuzer isn't in it but we lose nothing for having Casboult in the ruck but we gain a lot of around the ground possessions and he can play everywhere. I have gone for a small bench because the team looks tall as selected and we can use the entire bench through the forward line or the midfield and Jack can play tallish as well in defence or attack. I originally had Plowman for Marchbank but swapped them. As a result Plow plays twos. Newnes is a bit of a guess but they wouldn't have gone after him to play him in the NBs so I put him ahead of Williamson who also goes to the twos and not the bench. I was tempted to leave Simmo out but he is a clinch player and deserves a spot just for his gutsy on-field leadership. He will get squeezed out by Willo or SPS at some stage. I don't expect this team to ever be available and on the park. B. Marchbank Jones Newman HB. Doc Weitering Simpson C. Cunningham SPS Newnes HF. McGovern C.Curnow Martin F. Betts McKay Murphy R. Casboult Cripps Walsh Bench: Jack Setterfield Fisher Ed Almost: Dow, Gibbons, Williamson, Plowman, Stocker, Kennedy, Kreuzer. |
|
| Author: | bondiblue [ Thu Feb 27, 2020 1:09 pm ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Our best 22? |
Blue Sombrero wrote: OK. I think this is the best team we can put on the park. Yes, I know, Kreuzer isn't in it but we lose nothing for having Casboult in the ruck but we gain a lot of around the ground possessions and he can play everywhere. I have gone for a small bench because the team looks tall as selected and we can use the entire bench through the forward line or the midfield and Jack can play tallish as well in defence or attack. I originally had Plowman for Marchbank but swapped them. As a result Plow plays twos. Newnes is a bit of a guess but they wouldn't have gone after him to play him in the NBs so I put him ahead of Williamson who also goes to the twos and not the bench. I was tempted to leave Simmo out but he is a clinch player and deserves a spot just for his gutsy on-field leadership. He will get squeezed out by Willo or SPS at some stage. I don't expect this team to ever be available and on the park. B. Marchbank Jones Newman HB. Doc Weitering Simpson C. Cunningham SPS Newnes HF. McGovern C.Curnow Martin F. Betts McKay Murphy R. Casboult Cripps Walsh Bench: Jack Setterfield Fisher Ed Almost: Dow, Gibbons, Williamson, Plowman, Stocker, Kennedy, Kreuzer. I like what you've done there BS. I'd suggest the flipside to Almost is Just in: Newnes and Newman Kreuzer vs Casboult...anyones guess...Mr K has become leaner and has enjoyed a good preseason, barring the heart business, but Levi can't be left out with his preseason thus far, form last week and 2019 form (refer to BnF). I know he didn't get all those votes playing in the ruck, and he isn't as prevalent following up his own ruckwork as K, but he hurts like Mumford and is a great mark around the ground. I'm a Marchbank fan too. I don't believe we are too tall when Marchy and Plow play. It is not 1979: they are mobile talls. Marchy is a star and an amazing athletic specimen. He's been criticised for some of the daring kicks he took againstPies last year, but he hadn't played for such a long time. People forget how good he was as a kid, and his weapons. Williamson's form in the first and only praccy game against opposition suggested this kid is the real deal. If Willo can continue that vein of form in the next games vs Freo and Brizzy ... he's in....and he's got mongrel. I look forward to seeing an unsociable Carlton in 2020. Take no prisoners. I also believe Jack and Levi in the side give us flexibility lke no others, in case of injury during the game, and flexibility when we need to shake things up, forward, mid or back. If it was a GF, I'd certainly select both form permitting. The list is looking great when you look at the Almosts. The addition of Betts, Martin, Newnes, Docherty and Willo make a huge difference in a positive way. |
|
| Author: | Blue Sombrero [ Fri Feb 28, 2020 12:54 am ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Our best 22? |
Thanks, Bondi. After I did it, I compared it to Caz's and they are pretty similar. That made me feel better for a start. I couldn't believe how progressively harder this has become in the past few years, which is exactly what the rebuild was about. The 'Almosts' will play plenty of footy this year as injury and form demands weekly ins and outs. I am excited (again) but this time I think we really can jump a couple of ladder positions. The boys actually think they can win now. That makes a hell of a difference when they run out on the ground. |
|
| Author: | ferdinand [ Fri Feb 28, 2020 8:34 am ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Our best 22? |
I think given Plowman came third in the BnF last year he'll probably be in our best 22. |
|
| Page 165 of 172 | All times are UTC + 10 hours |
| Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/ |
|