CaptnCarlton wrote:
AGRO wrote:
Did Parkin talk about how he completely got the art of recruitment all cocked up and that by ignoring Under 18 Junior TAC talent and trying to find "mature bodied senior players from the SANFL, WAFL" etc that he really flowered up the future of the club.
Agro,
I think he come out publicly stating it was a major mistake, but had to follow JE's edict, there is no such thing as rebuilding. The board (JE) controlled a lot of which direction the recruiting went. The other thing was that they believed they had an opportunity for a final dig for a flag at the end of 2000/2001.
Parkin was a great coach and will forever be thankful that he was our coach.
However in this matter he was clearly wrong - and I think JE was more reliant on Parkin's advice in this regard than the other way around.
Parkin had a theory - that it was wrong to draft 17/18 year olds straight out of the TAC system - and thought that drafting mature 21/22 year olds out of the SANFL and WAFL would give us a strategic advantage, Elliott bought this theory.
The only problem was that the TAC pathway by that time had syphoned all the precocious talent and there was precious little left going through to the SANFL and WAFL and to a lesser extent the Victorian Country Leagues.
We recruited a "plethora" of mature bodied "duds" in the 90s when we shoudl have been recruiting the talent from the TAC system.
This was Parkins theory and fault - and Elliott relied on Parkin's advice it was not necessarily an Elliott directive.