TalkingCarlton :: View topic - What's your likely 22 v Fremantle?

I don't know why everyone here (or a lot of you, at least) want to see Eddie dropped.

He is a livewire, he will only improve with each game, and no one else on the list can offer what he can.

I think his performances so far this season have been outstanding. He may have only played 1 quarter against Port, and had no touches, but still laid 2 tackles.

Eddie should play.

Who's with me?

Bannister in.....Davies out

god this is hard.

i dont want to drop anyway one, but thorton is a must if he's fit.

same with campo you ould think although i'd rather he missed after he's shocker against the pies.

i want ot see banno and simmo in aswell!

it's gunna get worse when scotto comes back!

In: Campo
Out: McGrath

HB: Teauge Houlihan Lappin

I would personally like to see Campo playing in the Bullants for a month

Campo need a hand to take a bloody long hard look at himself IMHO

Quote:

I would personally like to see Campo playing in the Bullants for a month

Campo need a hand to take a bloody long hard look at himself IMHO

Would you like Carlton to win a game in the next month?

Camporeale is a leader at Carlton, one of our best players and highly respected by his opposition.

He has sacrificed his previous role in the team as a receiving runner for the team's benefit.

Belting Brodie Holland is fine by me and I daresay 99% of people on TC.

Campo hates to lose and wears the Navy Blue with pride and defends it harder than most. Don't irrationally crack the shits about his suspension.

Author:	Elroy [ Wed Apr 20, 2005 11:28 am ]
Post subject:	What's your likely 22 v Fremantle?
Here's mine: B: Carrazzo Norman Sporn HB: Teague Whitnall McGrath C: Lappin Houlihan Camporeale HF: Chambers Waite Walker F: Longmuir Fevola Betts Foll: French Koutafides Stevens I/C: Johnson Wiggins Deluca Davies In: Camporeale Out: Bowyer I feel for Glen, but at Subi we need to place a bit more emphasis on pace. I wouldn't be surprised, however, if Davies misses out instead. Your thoughts?

Author:	Humpers [ Wed Apr 20, 2005 11:40 am ]
Post subject:
I agree with your team Elroy. However I get the feeling that Betts will be the one to miss out this week.

Author:	Keith Urban [ Wed Apr 20, 2005 11:47 am ]
Post subject:
Richmond successfully tagged Hasleby and Josh Carr last week and we must do the same. For this reason I'd bring BANNISTER in and I'm afraid BETTS has to miss out. Either CARAZZO or BOWYER for CAMPOREALE.

Author:	Elroy [ Wed Apr 20, 2005 11:48 am ]
Post subject:
I don't know why everyone here (or a lot of you, at least) want to see Eddie dropped. He is a livewire, he will only improve with each game, and no one else on the list can offer what he can. I think his performances so far this season have been outstanding. He may have only played 1 quarter against Port, and had no touches, but still laid 2 tackles. Eddie should play. Who's with me?

Author:	molsey [ Wed Apr 20, 2005 11:54 am ]
Post subject:
Elroy wrote: I don't know why everyone here (or a lot of you, at least) want to see Eddie dropped. He is a livewire, he will only improve with each game, and no one else on the list can offer what he can. I think his performances so far this season have been outstanding. He may have only played 1 quarter against Port, and had no touches, but still laid 2 tackles. Eddie should play. Who's with me? God yeah Elroy - you can't just drop him after last weeks game, given performances in teh week before. With the Dockers chippy chip style, Eddie is going to create some turnovers this week. In the Goals / Accuracy article, the writer points out over 20 shots at goal between Eddie and Davies in the firs 4 rounds, mainly the first 3 rounds, surely a tasty coaching option. You can't dump your forward pockets to add a defender, your team will be out of balance. What you have to do is stick to your strengths, and I think our emerging forward line needs both Davies and Betts notwithstanding quieter games on the weekend. Therefore the dumping needs to come from the midfield if we are to include Campo - Bowyer or Johnson have to go despite their games on the weekend.

TalkingCarlton http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/

What's your likely 22 v Fremantle? http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=1575	Page 1 of 2

Author:	Elwood Blues1 [ Wed Apr 20, 2005 12:09 pm ]
Post subject:
I wouldnt drop Eddie...been good the first three weeks and gets to play in front of his mum and family this week and I reckon he will fire up for this game. Goalsneaks have their off days and Eddie is only a boy and learning the game..every game he plays improves him and its not good coaching to ditch a kid after one off game. Subi will suit him and give him plenty of room to work in and I reckon you can mark him down for a couple of goals minimum. I's like to include Bannister as insurance for Pavlich but its not easy dropping players like Bowyer who did the job asked of them last week and who has earned his spot... Kade Simpson must be close to selection as well..good form with the Bullants and the conditions at Subi will suit him as well... Bannister in.....Davies out

Author:	Elroy [ Wed Apr 20, 2005 12:22 pm ]
Post subject:
Quote: Bannister in.....Davies out Elwood, I respect your knowledge and opinions greatly, but surely Campo must come in?

Author:	Elwood Blues1 [ Wed Apr 20, 2005 1:04 pm ]
Post subject:
Sorry there Elroy...Campo will come in and probably for Bowyer even though I dont like dropping the ex Hawk after his good tagging efforts of last week. Should read Bannister in....Davies out Campo in.....Bowyer out(even though I hate doing it)

Author:	thegezman [ Wed Apr 20, 2005 1:12 pm ]
Post subject:
god this is hard. i dont want to drop anyway one, but thorton is a must if he's fit. same with campo you ould think although i'd rather he missed after he's shocker against the pies. i want ot see banno and simmo in aswell! it's gunna get worse when scotto comes back!

Author:	molsey [ Wed Apr 20, 2005 1:16 pm ]
Post subject:
thegezman wrote: god this is hard. i dont want to drop anyway one, but thorton is a must if he's fit. same with campo you ould think although i'd rather he missed after he's shocker against the pies. i want ot see banno and simmo in aswell! it's gunna get worse when scotto comes back! Sounds like your calling for injuries! Campo I can see back in the team, not suer about Scotland. I know people love him but Chambers can do the receiving job as good as anyone.

Author:	sticksaftersiren87 [ Wed Apr 20, 2005 1:35 pm ]
Post subject:
Ins Campo & Thornton/Simpson Outs: Betts (he's only 18, and he needs a full game in the 2s) and maybe McGrath

Author:	Pickle [ Wed Apr 20, 2005 2:01 pm ]
Post subject:
In: Campo Out: McGrath Think Cory had a great Wiz Cup but might be his turn for a week or two with the Bullants. Freo have a few mid size forwards so Bowyer will be needed down back. Eddie to get one more week up forward.

Author:	BlueJean [ Wed Apr 20, 2005 3:03 pm ]
Post subject:
Pickle wrote: In: Campo Out: McGrath I think so too.

Author:	billc3 [ Wed Apr 20, 2005 3:32 pm ]
Post subject:
Not sure what the roles were last week to be honest. McGrtah and Betts didn't get much time ...may well be a true horses for courses and at Subi pace and long kicking will be a premium... Having said that...despite a blinder ....Johnno may be an out

Page 1 of 2	All times are UTC + 10 hours
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/

Author:	ryan2000 [ Wed Apr 20, 2005 4:45 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: What's your likely 22 v Fremantle?
Mine - guessing on the fact that we wouldn't be dumb enough to choose Thornton! B: Carrazzo Norman Sporn HB: Teauge Houlihan Lappin C: Chambers Compo Walker HF: Waite Whitnall DeLuca F: Longmuir Fevola Betts Foll: French Kouta Stevens I/C: Johnson Davies Bannister Wiggins Just a thought..................but who else would like to see Eddie Betts tag Farmer. Hear me out! Last year, with the games that i watched eddie play in, he would piss of so many players because of his skills at goal, but also he's defensive work. And with Farmer easily being the most irritating player of all-time, put eddie on him and tell him to annoy the living shit out of him. Personally (and i don't think it'll happen) i rekon it's a great idea!

Author:	China Blues [ Wed Apr 20, 2005 4:53 pm ]
Post subject:
Must admit that I am a bit of a believer in playing the players who are in a bit of form, so Johnston and Bowyer to remain in the team selected. Also I am still really pissed off at Campo's lack of leadership and self-control in the Collingwood game, and the way he is constantly conned by opposition players to go the retaliation and then cop a suspension. Not much use to your team when your mind is on playing the man and not the ball, or you are watching from the sidelines because of suspension.. I know I am speaking from anger, but I would personally like to see Campo playing in the Bullants for a month, and give players like Johnston, Bowyer, Simmo, Bentick, Carrots, McGrath etc a chance and support to consistently have a crack at playing their hearts out for the jumper. Campo need a hand to take a bloody long hard look at himself IMHO.

Author:	Elroy [ Wed Apr 20, 2005 5:03 pm ]
Post subject:
Quote: HB: Teauge Houlihan Lappin Not sure about Houlihan at CHB

Author:	ryan2000 [ Wed Apr 20, 2005 5:05 pm ]
Post subject:
I like that idea! Just for something different maybe!

Author:	Elroy [ Wed Apr 20, 2005 5:17 pm ]
Post subject:
Quote: I would personally like to see Campo playing in the Bullants for a month Campo need a hand to take a bloody long hard look at himself IMHO Would you like Carlton to win a game in the next month? Camporeale is a leader at Carlton, one of our best players and highly respected by his opposition. He has sacrificed his previous role in the team as a receiving runner for the team's benefit. Belting Brodie Holland is fine by me and I daresay 99% of people on TC. Campo hates to lose and wears the Navy Blue with pride and defends it harder than most. Don't irrationally crack the shits about his suspension. [/quote]

Author:	molsey [ Wed Apr 20, 2005 5:24 pm ]
Post subject:
Elroy wrote: Quote: I would personally like to see Campo playing in the Bullants for a month Campo need a hand to take a bloody long hard look at himself IMHO Would you like Carlton to win a game in the next month? Camporeale is a leader at Carlton, one of our best players and highly respected by his opposition. He has sacrificed his previous role in the team as a receiving runner for the team's benefit. Belting Brodie Holland is fine by me and I daresay 99% of people on TC. Campo hates to lose and wears the Navy Blue with pride and defends it harder than most. Don't irrationally crack the shits about his suspension. [/quote] Is Elroy really Campo?