TalkingCarlton
http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/

Carlton's best second-hand player, 1990-now...
http://www.talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=14159		 Page 1 of 2
Author:  SparkyBlue [ Wed Jan 10, 2007 6:38 pm ]
Post subject:  Carlton's best second-hand player, 1990-now...
Don't know what got me thinking about this - but I was pondering the other day with a few mates at the pub about Carlton's best second-hand player since 1990... somebody who has been given more than a start at a previous club (or two) - at least say, 2 seasons and has for whatever reason been traded/poached/recycled to the Blues.

I was arguing the case for 2 hardnuts who happened to play in '95 GF - albeit for different sides (thanks keyser!), Williams and Hickmott... one a slow bastard with a savage handball and 2 (should be 3!) Brownlows under his belt, and the other a savage combination of the determination of Paul Kelly (the footballer!) and the courage of Glenn Archer. Both weren't a bad kick for goal either!

Any others worthy nominations who landed on Carlton's doorstep?

O'Reilly, Mansfield anyone?! :P
Author:  BlueWorld [ Wed Jan 10, 2007 6:42 pm ]
Post subject: 
Earl Spalding. Justin Madden.
Author:  Keyser Soze [ Wed Jan 10, 2007 6:46 pm ]
Post subject: 
Sorry Spark,

I'll think you'll find Hicky did indeed play in the 95 Grand Final but backed the wrong horse :wink:

No arguments about Williams but whether he was a real "second hand" player is debatable. When you're talking a second hand player for mine you're talking about a rejected player that turned into solid gold.

Under that criterion I'd like to give the nod to Brad Pearce who was absolutely pivotal to our 1995 success. I can remember spending the whole of 1995 saying "Who the hell is Brad Pearce?????" as he kicked yet another crucial goal.
Author:  TruBlueBrad [ Wed Jan 10, 2007 6:54 pm ]
Post subject: 
You are talking about different situations when a player is traded, such as Williams or Hickmott, to when he is discared by his former club and then drafted.

I'd have to think Dean Rice would be our best recycled pick up from the draft. Close behind would be Glen Manton.
Author:  Kouta [ Wed Jan 10, 2007 7:04 pm ]
Post subject: 
Matty Hogg.

We desperately need another back pocket like Matty who could be counted on to beat his man each week.

Didn't he play very well for the Big V on Wanganeen in one state of origin game? :?

Or am I confusing him with Hanna? :?
Author:  SparkyBlue [ Wed Jan 10, 2007 7:04 pm ]
Post subject: 
Sorry guys when I refer to second-hand - I'm basically saying the person played for a previous club, and came to our club under any capacity... traded, discarded and drafted and so on...

...I was wondering about the criteria myself, at the pub we initially argued on retreads/recycled players... then any play who came to our club from a previous club...

How long was Justin Madden at Essendon* before he came to the Blues? *got his bio in the lounge but can't be arsed checking!*

Rice would have been my third choice...
Author:  strangeblue [ Wed Jan 10, 2007 7:15 pm ]
Post subject: 
Mick McGuane, Mick Mansfield, Mick Martyn...

Hell, scratch anyone called Mick or Michael from the list.
Author:  Jarusa [ Wed Jan 10, 2007 7:20 pm ]
Post subject: 
SparkyBlue wrote:
Sorry guys when I refer to second-hand - I'm basically saying the person played for a previous club, and came to our club under any capacity... traded, discarded and drafted and so on...

...I was wondering about the criteria myself, at the pub we initially argued on retreads/recycled players... then any play who came to our club from a previous club...

How long was Justin Madden at Essendon* before he came to the Blues? *got his bio in the lounge but can't be arsed checking!*

Rice would have been my third choice...


Harry Madden's Profile

he was pre-1990 anyway.

... and Williams was third hand I think.
Author:  HTP [ Wed Jan 10, 2007 7:24 pm ]
Post subject: 
I'm a bit too busy cooking a BBQ and painting the laundry to read the initial post but if we're talking 2nd hand players that I've seen - Matthew Lappin by the length of a jolly long distance.

Having said that I've only been watching the fitba since '99.
Author:  HTP [ Wed Jan 10, 2007 7:26 pm ]
Post subject: 
Might whack Scotland and Stevens in a dead heat for second

And turn the sausages
Author:  Orangewhip [ Wed Jan 10, 2007 7:52 pm ]
Post subject: 
I don't want to type Jimmy Plunkett but I am.

Can't go past Hickmont though. He was a serious ginger bastard.
Author:  SparkyBlue [ Wed Jan 10, 2007 8:04 pm ]
Post subject: 
Orangewhip wrote:
I don't want to type Jimmy Plunkett but I am.

Can't go past Hickmont though. He was a serious ginger bastard.


Man, I always loved 'lil Jimmy Plunkett... he was like a ferret that somehow acquired the ball from a pack with ease - and then kick it f'ing anywhere (but usually to the opposition!)...

Ooh ooh ooh... I almost forgot Ron De Iulio...
Author:  timetodeliver2004 [ Wed Jan 10, 2007 8:35 pm ]
Post subject: 
Matt Clape anyone?
Author:  Orangewhip [ Wed Jan 10, 2007 9:19 pm ]
Post subject: 
SparkyBlue wrote:
Orangewhip wrote:
I don't want to type Jimmy Plunkett but I am.

Can't go past Hickmont though. He was a serious ginger bastard.


Man, I always loved 'lil Jimmy Plunkett... he was like a ferret that somehow acquired the ball from a pack with ease - and then kick it f'ing anywhere (but usually to the opposition!)...



:wink:

And there's never been a better name than PLUNKETT to yell out at the footy.
Author:  Pat's Fitztrick [ Wed Jan 10, 2007 9:36 pm ]
Post subject: 
Diesel - definitely.
But then he was targeted as a trade.
So was Harry Madden.
And Matty Lappin.

Of those that came to us virtually unwanted - Hickmott, Clape, Pearce and Manton are all strong contenders - and who could forget Val 'Woof' Perovic?

But for mine, the number one retread has to be Jim Francis (captain, Best & Fairest, 1938 Premiership player, senior coach, Hall of Fame).
Author:  Trem [ Wed Jan 10, 2007 10:31 pm ]
Post subject: 
Harry came from the Bombers for the 1983 season after 45 games there - don't ask how I remember that but I know it's a fact.

I tend to think that the criteria of 'discarded player' is the more interesting one. Sure we got Williams and he was a champ, but it didn't take any particular wisdom to secure him, just money and the chance to win a flag.

Pearcy, Dean Rice, Hoggy
Author:  Navy One [ Wed Jan 10, 2007 11:04 pm ]
Post subject: 
The '95 Premiership Team had 8 who started at previous clubs. Not a bad bunch .....

Clape
Hogg
Madden
Manton
Pearce
Rice
Spalding
Williams
Author:  Rambo Stallone [ Thu Jan 11, 2007 2:20 am ]
Post subject: 
The one and only Tim Powell,the legend
Author:  Deano Supremo [ Thu Jan 11, 2007 6:06 am ]
Post subject: 
Rambo Stallone wrote:
The one and only Tim Powell,the legend


I thought you'd be a Mark Athorn man :lol:
Author:  Sumo [ Thu Jan 11, 2007 6:15 am ]
Post subject: 
Under the criteria mentioned, Williams easily
Page 1 of 2 All times are UTC + 10 hours
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/