Looks like this isn't going to be published on the club site, so I put it in the Blueseum.
http://www.blueseum.org/cfc/tiki-read_a ... ticleId=13
The criteria was basically not comparing entire careers but what particular players did in the 1980's.
The top 10 I came up with was:
1. Wayne Johnston
2. Stephen Kernahan
3. Bruce Doull
4. Ken Hunter
5. Wayne Harmes
6. Peter Bosustow
7. David Rhys-Jones
8. Justin Madden
9. Rod Ashman
10. David Glascott
Some great names were left out. Who would make your top 10?