Blue Vain wrote:
Young's last chance this week but I'd forget the ruck role. He was playing OK until we changed his role.
I'm coming around to the thoughts about playing TDK in defence. If we're going to play a tall defender in the ruck (which I don't like), I'd rather it be Tom.
JSOS needs a role other than FP but the wing rotation isn't working. He needs to play relieving ruck or play 2's.
I'd settle the defence, bring in Cottrell and Owies for Hollands and Honey. Kennedy in to the 22, Walsh to high H/F.
I keep hearing how we can't play Cripps, Hewett, Kennedy and Cerra in the middle. It worked OK earlier last year. Our mids brutalised their opponents. We need to get back to that. No excuses. If they cant execute their role. Step aside and give someone else a shot.
Lastly, get some cameos going in the middle. Durdin, Motlop. Even Acres. Change it up.
B: Cincotta, Young, McGovern
HB: Docherty, Weitering, Saad
C: Acres, Cripps, Cottrell
HF: Owies, Harry, Walsh
F: Motlop, Charlie, Durdin
Foll: Pittonet, Kennedy, Cerra
Int: Kemp, Hewett, Ed, Silvagni
Sub: Boyd
Young on his last chance for what position and why? are you talking about KPD-ruck? For TDK?
If so, has TDK ever been played as a KPD since he was drafted?
I'd like to see TDK play KPD in the reserves first and get some development under his belt rather than throwing him under the bus.
I like all the suggested changes I'm reading, and there's heaps of good suggestions to find the best spot for 22 players, and they make my ears prick.
I think our best intercept mark is the same guy who was the same best intercept mark in the TAC when he was playing there: Weitering.
Weiters form hasn't been great vs Saints and Lions. Young hasn't been worse imo. The turnovers haven't been unhelpful for KPD's.
It seems we are experimenting in the backline with Cincotta & Kemp playing their 2nd game there. Add TDK, and its a backline that hasnt played much together at all, let alone having secured their spots in the backline. Add Newman's suspension, and I would call our backline unsettled.
I get we are a work in progress, but our backline was our stregth. They arent the ones who missed easy shots at goal that cost us vs Saints, nor creating the 85 points kicked against us from turnovers.
I'm looking forward to Boyd getting back to last year's form and get him in. Farmer thinks he's worth the risk. I'm just saying he didnt look like an inform player knocking down the door. If he didnt do all the kick ins, he would have been ... missing altogether.
I was kinda hoping Sam Durdin and Young could take KPDs to allow Weitering to control the air ...if he was in form.