Sidefx wrote:
SurreyBlue wrote:
Sidefx wrote:
SurreyBlue wrote:
keogh wrote:
Acres is dropped
Has 62 fantasy points in the magoos 2 weeks ago then doesn’t play last week
Billy Wilson has 110 and 113 but can’t even crack
It for a spot as an emergency
Go figure
Same sh1t - but we have no depth with players such as LCampo, Binns, Wilson, Boyd.
So who would you replace for Wilson or Boyd - Cowan, Hollands, Carroll or Doc in his last game?
And would you put Binns or L Campo in before Acres if he is fit to play in Doc's last game?
As you all know, I am not an Acres fan, but I have no issue with the ins this week.
Boyd before Acres and Harry should have had a run in the VFL first. Just no standards.
Boyd is not a wing though and you don't run your top 6 players through the VFL unless you have exceptional depth and even then, I doubt there are many clubs that would anyway.
I get you want standards, we all do, but you are overvaluing the list again.
Don't get me wrong, I like Boyd and his speed and kicking, but he is also not consistent and hasn't really stood out this year when he has played and from reports, he hasn't really stood out in the VFL either.
As for Harry, who would you play forward instead of him, Lemmey?
Who had 4 disposals and 1 goal on the weekend, that's not my idea of standards.
Common sense sidey
I love Boydy and have looked for reasons why he is being over looked.
He looks like an AFL player with his kicking, but he's lost a yard, and is finding it hard to break lines.
Most of his possessions are cheapies: either from kick ins, or on his own behind the ball taking uncontested marks.
There's been a lot turnovers from him this year. There's reasons why this year isn't his.
As a 28yo, what I want to know is if he has passed his peak. It may well be the case, but I'm blaming his disrupted preseason, even after 17 rounds of footy.