Gilly34 wrote:
get rid of the hacks wrote:
White hasn't played an AFL game.....too earlly to say we found a smokie, or was even value where picked, WC passed on him for JON after he had trained with them.......but Garlett is one WH did find.
Armfield was a smokie for those that rate him.
AJ a rookie selection too.
I dont really care which state our smokies come from as long as we find them anyway.
We need to get more ruthless trading out older players when our window is shut.
Knocking back a 1st rounder for Lance the year before he was sacked a prime example.
Not much room left for sentiment anymore.
Such a bloody boring stickler/party pooper

.....I've seen White play often enough to reckon he's as good a chance as anyone out there in the RD.....In my haste to reply I also could have mentioned Armfield or Garlett, either way I think the point has been made

LOL stickler / party pooper

....but I know u rated White.
So far I have heard/read comments we have recruited the following in a draft lamented by all recruiters and described as having about 30 AFL quality kids
1/Lucas....should have gone higher
2/Davies....toughest HB since Glen Archer but 191cm with lots of run
3/Rohan Kerr....mecurial small fwd
Rookied
1/Cachia...should have #16 in ND not #16 in RD
2/Dare....was really a 3rd round ND quality player
3/Casboult....the next Kurt Tippet
4/White...one of 90 Andrew Mackies drafted this year
5/Donaldson....super athletic tall who someone stated they are sure he will make it.
I would tell Eddie to "Lock it in" on Lucas playing 100 games barring injury
Apart from Lucas give me 1 specific player you would back at even money to get to 100 games......I doubt even WH would take such a bet on, even if it was 50 games.
Long gone are the days when u get a game at Carlton for the Cranages, Prendegasts, Merringtons
Even if White (picked at 150 approx) is the 40th best from this draft it might not be enough to get him to 20 games.
With our 2nd pick @ 43 we got a bunch of lottery tickets after the 1st rounder. Yes there are a few prizes still to be won.
If 2 kids apart from Lucas turn out to be regulars the recruiters have done a magnificent job.....which 2 are your $ on Gilly

?
Don't get me wrong I think the recruiters did well.....but with the picks we had in a shallow/compromised draft 2 kids making it would be a par result....3 great.....4 absolutely spectacular.
So I'm just finding it a little hard to get too optimistic about pick 150 just yet
