Why are you even replying to the brain dead!!

Decision making is what it came down to. GWS have some if the highest draft picks in the last 3 years and it shows, there is a quality amongst top end draft picks that distinguishes themselves from the best and the middle end, which is what we have in carrazzo. Maclean and Robinson. Congilio killed us

_________________
'too young to remember 95', have envied other clubs since'

This is true, we had our chance and blew it.

Time to take our medicine again.

What sucks is the delight everyone takes in seeing us fail.

You don't get that supporting the Roos or Dees.

_________________
We are eternal, all this pain is an illusion.

Thomas in his 12 th game for the club was the one talking to the players.Yeah had a shit tackling game... but thats Murphy most weeks.
Its a Carlton disease...

Now... prove we would have won with the super tackler and finisher Murphy in the side.
simple....

I know what my eyes have told me over Murphys 8 years at the club.. he doesnt tackle anywhere near Thomas does.

Of course were talking over a career and not a game....

But how much do you want that ticket around the world Cimm?
How about $5000 in cash...

_________________
Due to recent budget cuts and the rising cost of electricity, gas, and oil....... the Light at the End of the Tunnel has been turned off. We apologize for the inconvenience.

terrible stat but let's face it, 5 years of poor recruiting and player development will kill any side

it doesn't really matter how many tackles we lay when our disposal by hand and foot is so deplorable

turnovers destroyed our chances today and has been the case all year

we simply don't have the cattle

we can analyse and discuss all we want but ultimately it's all futile as we have no choice but to begin again

Anyone posting that we had 35 tackles today is a liar.

Its the poor decision making that gets me.
Poor skills are one thing but bad decisions is another. The number of times there were 2 blues and 2 gws going for the ball and both our players went for the ball leaving their bloke loose was crazy.
Bad players maybe
Poorly coached absolutely
They looked lost confused and disinterested .This is coaching

_________________
If you allow the Government to change the Laws in an emergency
They will create an Emergency to change the Laws

Given you posted this twice, I hope you used TWO exception permits. No cheating now.....

_________________
Never argue with idiots. They drag you down to their level and then beat you with experience!!!

After Monday and Tuesday, even the calendar says W T F .........
Visit http://fromthemoshpit.com/

Lets talk about today Synbad.

Nobody can prove anything, but my eyes told me
the ball came out of the forwardline very easily. Eddie and Jeffy used to hold it in pretty well.
Thomas could not make a metre when chasing.
Thomas missed tackles.
We played very poorly.
Murphs 25+ possessions would have been worth a kick and a half.

Did I miss anything?

The work rate of the last month or so wasn't there. Why not.

That's not a talent issue.

you also mentioned a clean out of the coaching staff. Their Micks coaches surely. There's no reason he has to put up with donkeys, that's in his control.

_________________
I hope Essendon* folds.

And that is why I don't understand when so many people think we should massively cull our list? Get rid of who, and replace them with who? Can you imagine having 27 first round draft picks? They say the days of Carlton just opening up the checkbook are over, and they are, now the new "Carlton" is the AFL itself, who don't bother with checkbooks, they own the game. A new market in Greater Western Sydney to tap into, a predominantly rugby minded market, and what better way (tried & tested via Swans, Port, Brisbane and Eagles) to capture that market than a flag winning dynasty?
It worked for Brisbane didn't it? Now Brisbane have a somewhat diehard crowd behind them. And there's no doubt the AFL isn't trying to set up "THE DERBY" between Swans/GWS Brisbane/GCS in this latest round of lets royally screw over the game for a few years at the expense of the rest of the league whilst we establish new markets with our vast wealth and sporting clout.

We should have been WELL ahead on this. Why has it only now we are saying our recruiting needs to be seriously looked at? o.O

Did we as a club have any inkling that new teams would be given 27, twenty seven, first round draft picks and what that would do to the talent pool available to us at the time?

I'm seriously beginning to think its going to be a LOOOOOOONG time before we see September glory. I'd dare to wager GWS & GCS will see September glory before we do ...

dont go overboard verbsy... have another beer.
my footy info phone app had that after the game and then has refreshed. to 56.

_________________
Due to recent budget cuts and the rising cost of electricity, gas, and oil....... the Light at the End of the Tunnel has been turned off. We apologize for the inconvenience.

The good thing is a) the current situation will facilitate far more change then ending up in 9th or 10th spot b) we getter better picks.

_________________
TC suffers from the social media illness - the death of respect and constructive discourse by keyboard.

Thomas over commits to his tackling. He often runs himself out of the contest chasing a tackle that was never there. Head down tucked into his shoulder. He isn't that great. Today terrible. There are missed tackles and there are missed tackles.
Murphy takes the tagger. Today Simpson copped the tagger and was easily taken out of the game.

Micks structures are terrible. He is still back in 2010 trying to get the old swarm going. Doesn't realize teams long ago learned how to deal with it.
What we are left with is 10 blokes swarming towards the ball while the opposition holds it shape. Flips it over the top and we are left with no defense. It is terrible.
Our players run hard but the system they play doesn't allow them to succeed.

Mick was outcoached by a bloke who coached from ground level and barracked for his team. Not sure if he was eating lollies though.

Think. Then post.

srry.. thats too ludicrous to win $5000 for spinning shit.... its fanciful and something thats going on in your head.. when u were a kid did u make that cheering noises as you counted down the gameclock of the game you were playing out in your mind and snapped a winner on the siren to win the flag??.. and then gave a crowd cheer... ???

you did didnt you...???

now if you had of said Selwood or Hodge i would have no comeback... but you used a guy who has been criticised time and time again in the media for his defensive softness as your example...
a guy who by YOUR VERY OWN admission couldnt have been soft today because he didnt play....

_________________
Due to recent budget cuts and the rising cost of electricity, gas, and oil....... the Light at the End of the Tunnel has been turned off. We apologize for the inconvenience.

Shane Mumford... 55 hitouts - 18 disposals - 9 tackles

_________________
“I would rather have questions that can't be answered than answers that can't be questioned.” ― Richard Feynman

What has MM got to lose know surely he will give brock , carrots , warnock , white , Curnow the flick and play some of
the younger players

Probably phased out 'Finals' Laidler to free up some cash for his Daisy too.

Yep I am going to consider that fact from now on.

And he is in $750 K pa

_________________
TC suffers from the social media illness - the death of respect and constructive discourse by keyboard.

Since when has work rate not been a talent issue, or did I miss something?

_________________
Just because I'm offended, doesn't mean I'm wrong.