Mil Hanna wrote:
WA Blue wrote:
Who really thinks that act was worth 3 WEEKS?
The act was dumb, stupid, pathetic all of that but,
3 weeks is a disgrace. No injury to the victim, no reaction form the victim.
What is the game coming to. 1 week would have sufficed. That behaviour should not be in our game but 3 weeks is laughable. And I'm not sooking just because it's Judd .
Maxwell broke someones jaw and got donuts.. How does that work?
Exactly, the whole thing is a load of bullshit.....
Regardless of the dumb act itself or the silly things Judd said to the media, there is no way in hell that is worth 3 weeks, and that's what he got - forget about the guilty plee, 2 week thing - he got 3 weeks!! For touching someone's face innappropriately FFS.... Should have been offered 2 or 1 and he would have pleaded guilty, then it's all over.
You can clear-as-day punch someone in the face and get less than 3 weeks, it's just so stupid. This match review panel is a crock of shit, it does not take into account the particulars of a situation, the only thing it offers is that players clearly know what to expect from it's findings; the worst penalty available.
The fact is he did something stupid, no harm was caused to anyone, nor was there a complaint from the other player and he should have been either reprimanded or given 1 week. The way I see it is that he had no option but to take it to the tribunal and then appeal, because it's just such a stupid penalty for such a nothing event.
Has the world gone mad??
at least some people get it.
man some of the people are so shit scarred of what might happen that they prefer to take two weeks rather than risk three.
bollocks to both.
at most, and i mean at most, its nothing more serious than a wrestling charge. he didnt eye guage, he wasnt attempting to eye guage. is it any different than if judd had a handful of mud and rubbed in riscetlli's face?
dam straight the club appeals, to think buddy can get two weeks for ko's, maxwell four weeks for breaking a jaw, then get off ... and judd get three weeks for a hand in the face that cause not an injury in the slightest, is just laughable.
its a reprimand at most with a fine.
but take the two weeks, we dont want to make them angry
_________________
Got to love the stare Down by Setanta on Llyod
Login
Register
FAQ
