Just got back myself (went down Lygon with my old man afterwards to have a bite), and quite happy with the overall result. Yes, this was just a practice game but there are two things I think are important to mention
1) This was a strong Bulldogs team with few (if any) players out, and if you look at their best it was the usual suspects. Whereas for us it was a combination of experienced players and kids.
2) The spirit around the ground was addictive, and no doubt that, with the inclusion of Judd in the middle, energised the players even more. Their confidence grows.
Scrappy first quarter, which has been a symptom of our whole pre-season thus far. Took a little while to settle down. Doggies definitely looked sharper at the beginning of the game, and more importantly took advantage of their opoprtunities (with quite a lot of help from the umps mind you). For the first 10-15 minutes it looked like a finals contender playing a bottom side. But once the boys settled down, they gradually wore them down, and the Dogs were under constant pressure and making lots of mistakes, which was the opposite of the first qtr.
Judd: Was on and off the field A LOT. That he could still rack up 20 possies is a sign of how good this guy is. Hearing the crowd go up with every touch of the ball I think was duplicated amongst the playing group. You could tell they wanted to play harder with this bloke around. Played well, didn't end up sore, kicked a goal. I love the man.
Kreuzer: Again, practice game. But if this is what we can expect from this young man on a regular basis, we've got something special on our hands. Moves very well (ran down a couple of smaller Doggies players on different occasions), has great smarts, and definitely held his own against a very good ruck pairing for the dogs. Seemed to be everywhere in the 2nd half, and his commitment and second efforts are astounding. Will be a star.
Murphy: I didn't see the incident involving Hahn (my view was blocked), but honestly didn't think it could've been too serious given that none of the Doggies players remonstrated after the fact. So I thought it had to be just a solid but fair bump. Excellent again, and forget all this bullshit about poor kicking, the guy's poise is superb. Will be a major feature in our engine room this year. Carrots fits the same bill too.
Simpson: BOG in the first half for me. Speed, commitment, courage. The works. Also looks to have developed an ok right foot too.
Gibbs: Didn't see him get A LOT of the ball (was hard to see sometimes), but when he did have it always (except for one time) delivered it precisely and calmly.
Waite/Bower: Kept our defence together. In the first half when Thornton, Jamison and Setanta were all struggling, it was these two that slowed the bleeding. Then in the second half both would back themselves at every opportunity and in the case of Waite, would produce special moments. With Thornton and Jamison looking after things down back in the 2nd half, these two set up many of our attacking runs.
Fev: Looked like he was going to mark everything in the first half. The big dukes are most certainly back, and his second efforts continue to improve. Still missed a few, but in fairness he didn't have many easy shots.
Edwards: Pencil this guy in for round 1. Marking, kicking, presenting. Probably equal with Fev today as our most potent forward. A player this one.
Walker: I thought when he laid the tackle that he seemed to go in too hard for the situation, then when he stayed down I got worried. I didn't know whether it was his shoulder or something else. I saw him leave the ground, but thought it couldn't be too serious because he had his hands up to his head (which told me it couldn't be a serious shoulder problem) and he wasn't limping. So my thoughts were that he'd be sore, might miss a couple, but more likely will be alright. Time will tell though.
Browne: Loved his endeavour, and how even for one so young and inexperienced, he doesn't back down. Will be a very good tough-nut for us, but still seems to be adjusting to the pace of AFL, as he got caught a couple of times.
Cloke: As always, tried his guts out all-day, and will provide that solid body in the ruck to give our young'uns some respite. Hate to use the word, but definitely has presence.
Hartlett: Just good to see him playing and moving freely. Would've been better if he kicked a goal or two though.
Houlihan, Thornton, Setanta, Betts, Russell: Just didn't play well. Although Houlihan and Thornton did improve as the game wore on. The others struggled.
Hampson, Hadley, Bannister: Were constantly running off and on the ground, so didn't really get much chance to do much. Ratts obviously wanted to nurse them through it.
I'm probably missing a few, but these are the ones I remember. Although on the negative side we still are struggling with, although these all should improve:
- Handballing to stationary/about to be tackled targets
- Kicking for goal
- Sloppy tackling
- Tunnel-vision when going forward
- Not using the corridor enough (played much better when we did)
Overall though, a great day, a very good win against a quality opponent, and hopes we'll only get better from here.
|