Cazzesman wrote:
jimmae wrote:
Cazzesman wrote:
Your view on the selection decision this week, and who was in line for consideration? I just thought we had an opportunity to blood a few and rest some others.
Jimmae I don't have an opinion because I don't have enough information about who is fit to play and who is not. Who is mentally on the ball and who is not.
I don't know who has been given instructions and roles to play in the VFL and who has carried those instructions and/or roles out well. I don't have the detailed analysis that Cordy has regarding who; needs to be rested and who needs to keep playing based on the fact that a bye is not far away.
I can't read between the lines regarding what Ratts said about Carrots running well and whether he was ready to play this week.
I don't know where Austin, Bower and Lucas are at in regards to their mindset and/or fitness to play AFL.
I do know you can't fit 25 into 22 and if some worthy choices are still missing out of the team then that can only be a good thing. I don't know but I can surmise the MC want to try and settle down the team leading into the finals but we are still awaiting the return of Hammer, Waity, Jamo, Carrots, Curnow, Paul Bower and JR. So that means there are 4 or 5 who are currently playing that have their spots up for grabs.
Those players are obviously; Touhy, Davies, Armfield, McLean, Houls, AJ and maybe Ellard. So I would surmise it may be abit pointless to start bringing others into the team at this late stage to cloud the issue. That is not to say it won't happen but I don't know why it would.
Regards CazzesmanWe may as well not have this discussion board.
By extension of "I don't have an opinion because I don't have the knowledge or expertise", that might be true of expert evidence in legal proceedings, but you are saying that unless you have knowledge, don't express your opinion, even if it's hypothetical.
I may disagree with many on this board, but I will defend their right to say it unless it is defamatory or illegal. You keep rolling your eyes at people who express their opinions, such expression many find somewhat cathartic. With all due respect, that point of view leads to a "I know more than you so there" atmosphere to the forum, which I'm sure, people don't appreciate.