club29 wrote:
Maybe we need to slot him into one of our quicker line ups so he can be covered. Like the teams we put out in the first 3 rounds but swap him for Curnow. Then we fans will truly know if he can play a part.
The coaches probably already know. They measure his metres per minute. They know how many contests he gets to and whether he is playing his role defensively. I will leave the call up to them.
I was thinking about Mclean slotting into a line up with Kreuzer, Hampson, Judd, Murphy, Carrazzo, Yarran, Simpson, Robinson, Walker, Garlett, Gibbs, Armfield and Lucas. Shame the match committee doesn't appear willing to give it a go with Curnow out. Working Mclean into a quick line up would be a worthy experiment against the Giants.
Mclean and Ellard are better "grunts" than Murphy. One of Geelong's former leaders stated that one of their players would give a teammate a wink and roll over onto Ablett's opponent so he could get free. Murphy could have taken responsibility for Stanton and manned him up like Bradley used to do to Hocking or Matera. Guess it's easier to blame Brock for the downhill skiing and leave the stars alone like fanboys.
For some reason you have Murphy in your sights Kouta. They guy is a star. B&F winner. Multiple runner ups. His role to me looks like an attacking role along with Judds. Blokes like Carrazzo , Curnow and at times Armfield are there to make sure their attacking play has some cover. Murphy is frequently in packs. He has the strength now to keep his feet in them and is one tough player.
Along with the rest of the team his game wasnt top notch last week but he will bounce back. The blues copping a hammering in the ruck wouldnt of helped his game..
Not sure we wanted him matching up Stanton. Robbing peter to pay paul there.