blueboy23 wrote:
Cheers harker,
Question mate, what are your thoughts on
-do you think Watson/McCarthy will make it?
-how far away are Buckley/menzel?
-could we land someone like, Tom lynch from Gold Coast?
-does Mitchell have what it takes?
-what's the go with laidler and duigan? duigan was almost our skipper
Sorry for the questions, but I value your opinion and you make great sense
cheers bud
I'm far from an expert and don't live at the CFC so can really only comment on what I see taking into account a little inside info now and then.
Watson:
I'd feel better about him if his arms were 5cm longer. Seems to lack reach and misses important spoils by just a bit. That bit is all important though.
He's not the fastest and I would have said far from the smartest last year, but seems to have a good handle on his job and the job of others around him right now.
McCarthy:
I'll feel better about McCarthy when he smacks an opponent in the mouth. I don't really mean that but would just love to see a hunger that seems to be missing right now.
Moves well has the smarts but just doesn't "seem" to dig in.
Menzel:
Pretty clear he'll make for a player, a very good player.
Happy to mix it up against men even now. Still travelling at 3/4 pace but you can just tell.
Buckley:
If he doesn't make it, it won't be for lack of trying.
His good is very good but has to put together a full game for which I haven't seen yet and not even in the game that had him earn his AFL debut.
Burst player right now and that's just not enough. Has plenty of time on his side and will be given a contract come years end.
Mitchell:
Looked better to me in last years pre-season than he did through this last one.
A few here have knocked him and for good reason at times, but some of the delivery to him at the VFL level is just shocking.
Makes good in his leads and the ball either gets dropped on his head or he's forced to stop and prop. That movement doesn't serve him too well.
I believe that MM may have just told him not to expect a game this year and it's all about getting his game right. Has some way to go yet but has been improving in recent weeks.
Duigan:
Currently can't see him getting another game at AFL level.
Love the guy and the efforts he brings but you he hasn't the tools needed against the types he'd have to play on.
Laidler:
Not sure what turn of events has put him in this situation.
His knee? Discipline? Team Balance? I don't know. There is plenty being written up about him and plenty of questions being asked. I haven't the answers.
Wouldn't be surprised should Judd step down this year and gives us the salary cap space to attack a couple of premium players. Think we'll know about Judd in a couple of months.
Expecting to lose anything up to 10 players at years end. Not all of them will relieve any substantial cap space, but the spots will be there.