Paddycripps wrote:
bondiblue wrote:
AFL injury Report and whose in the Mix
Quote:
St Kilda could regain Max King just a month after he dislocated his shoulder in round 17. The 23-year-old will need to prove his fitness later in the week but is a chance to face Carlton on Sunday. Bradley Hill is on track to play after missing the win over Hawthorn on Sunday. Tim Membrey returned in the VFL and could be in line for a recall. Jack Hayes has now played two VFL games and a practice match and could be ready for another chance at AFL level after recovering from a knee reconstruction. Nick Coffield and Tom Highmore were both impressive in the VFL on Saturday. - Josh Gabelich
R20 sub: Jade Gresham (replaced Zak Jones)
Will Gresham make the Best 23 with Cooper Sharman has being cleared of serious damage after the club thought he had strained his hamstring at Marvel Stadium on Sunday.
Sharman played on Sicily, subduing the star defender while kicking two goals of his own. Hill will come in for Jones imo. Who comes out for King after Caminiti was cleared to play?
Jones is out for the rest of the season. I'm afraid Gresham's spot in the Bset 23 is precarious. Good depth for Saints to have up their sleeve for Sub
After missing three games after dislocating the shoulder he had reconstructed in December, King is pushing to return against the Blues this weekend.
King has been earmarked and prepared for this do or die Finals like game vs Carlton. He underwent an arthroscope on his shoulder after dislocating it in round 17.
Let me say that again. Dislocation, Arthroscope, misses 3 games and returns after 4 weeks. Confirms my thoughts on Harry McKay's return as early as the Melbourne game, and should be the GCS and GWS games.
This makes no sense.
Just because one team is desperate doesn't mean we need to be.
I'm not sure if you are saying what I posted makes no sense because of my bad grammar, sentence structure, tense, or is it the point about a possible return of Harry 4 weeks after an arthroscope?
If the latter, it does make sense, and I'm not saying its a definite. Its not a definite. Neither is the 5-8 weeks quoted by Andrew Russell. Are you thinking its definitely 5-8 weeks for Harry?
I'm giving evidence about the arthroscope King had, and the time it took to heal from that.
If Harry has recovered, that is not 'desperate" to play him. If he hasn't recovered and is selected, that is desperate.
Lets see paddy. Harry has form returning 2-3 weeks earlier than expected.
Same person has set the expectation this time as the last time he was out for a long period.
Its good news if Harry is back for last 2 games, if not last 3 games. If not....bad luck.
Neither of us know. There is no definite, just hope from my end.
I'd place a bet he will be back with 8 weeks after arthroscope (Monday 17th July). ie before 11 sept.
In fact, I'd place a bet he plays another H&A game (last one is 27th August) and the game before that too. Just a hunch.
Login
Register
FAQ
Search
