What concerns me in this is what was it that Collingwood saw (or didn't see) in Voss that it did not select him over McRae ?

In all fairness, I watched 2 of his gf losses over the weekend and he came within a bees dick of winning them. Cruel game.

What concerns me in this is what was it that Collingwood saw (or didn't see) in Voss that it did not select him over McRae ?

They were probably valued a different criteria to us.

Some people value tactics, some value relationship building, some value toughness, some value all of the above.

Also certain people make more of an impression than others.

Human Nature !! Wrong or Right Fit. It’s a Vibe thing sometimes.

Hard to know if things work out with anyone.

Ok so if its true that we havent yet appointed a coach and are hiring assistants. This makes me uneasy.

I think the coach should choose his own assistants, and together they need to trust eachother and get along for them as a group to be successful.

Am I reading this wrong?

This is reminicent of when we appointed Teague, he inherited the assistants he had.

I wonder if we have a final crack at C Scott. He should relish the new challenge and might have hit his ceiling at Geelong

McRae is off the table.

Move on.

Simple answer. They had a choice and took one.
Whose got the crystal ball to say they were on the money or not!

That's the answer. No right or wrong....especially from anyone outside that room.
They had their reasons, and they might not be ours.

McRae is gone. Next.

Love your schtick bondi, but I think you misread my point

Matthews, who used to coach Voss as a player at Brisbane, said it was “no surprise” to see him the hot favourite to succeed David Teague in the role.

“He’s had the apprenticeship,” he said of Voss on Sportsday.

“We talk about (new Collingwood coach), Craig McRae who’s had the 15-year apprenticeship post-playing and Michael Voss has had about 12 years. I’m a great believer that whatever you do, you’re going to be better because of experience.

“I think Michael (Voss) will be a much better senior coach, it’s not a surprise that he’s popped up as the best of the available options.

“Michael coached and got the Lions into the finals one year and then didn’t have that ultimate success, there isn’t a problem of him wanting to chuck himself back into the lifestyle (of being a senior coach).

“The experience of having actually coached…it should be more valuable than someone who hasn’t done it.”

What concerns me in this is what was it that Collingwood saw (or didn't see) in Voss that it did not select him over McRae ?

Barass’s comments on BF tonight all but confirm Voss will be coach …

https://www.sen.com.au/news/2021/09/21/leigh-matthews-endorses-carltons-likely-next-coaching-appointment/

The GOAT's thoughts.

Regards Cazzesman

Can someone paraphrase what he said?

The 7th member of our coaching selection panel

Talk about media driven drivel to
Force Carlton to take Voss