Sydney Blue wrote:
ryan2000 wrote:
I don't see why would we even bother with McLean?
He's shown nothing in 3 years? What's gonna happen if we pick him this weekend? What - he's all of a sudden gonna play a blinder racking up 40possesions and 5 goals?????

Doubt it.
I watched him in the VFL this weekend and he looked out of his depth.
Forget him........... move on...........
I'd be bringing in Bootsma and Lucas (only due to injury) and Waite (if fit).
Russell should be banished (but Ratt's loves him so he won't be)
Has Brock been given a chance to establish himself in the side - He hasn't played more than 2 games in a row since he was drafted 3 years ago-
blokes like Duigan- Curnow- Touhy- Armfield - Ellard - Russell - Lucas have been given huge blocks of games and not produced consistantly - Yet Brock is expected to walk in and tear it up first game back
The way the club and supporters have treated this bloke is disgraceful
Brock was offered a 1 year contract with Demons, and we offered him 3 years.
I think the club has done the right thing by him and his savings account...don't you worry about that.
I'd say Armfield has earned his spot and also had to put up with a bit of bias against...if it is bias you are suggesting.
Army brings good negating skills, intensity and pace to get to a contest which Brock doesn't: sure he lacks a bit of class, but makes up for that and is ahead of the so called 'better' players on our list.
I agree with Ryan, and I'd suggest that Brock has not shown much when given an opportunity...even in his last game against his old side, against kids he missed sitters and really didn't show he was better than the kids.
Having said that, I wouldn't mind him coming in and showing some of that grunt he can give us, to save the frail undeveloped body of a first or second year pup. We are desperate...the cupboard is bare. So bare we may have to put up with Russell, the underdone Duigan and Curnow (although he did do some very very good things on the weekend, including desire for the contest).
Stick Tuohy in the guts and lets see what he can offer....against kids. Have to say he is a very nice kick though.