take away La Cras and they kicked what 3 goals?

_________________
This type of slight is alien in the more cultured part of the world - Walsh. Its up there with mad dogs, Englishmen and the midday sun!

He plays for us so that is good.

Thank god or Dick Pratt

WTF
Take away his balls and my uncle is my aunty.
Judd out would mean Kennedy and Masten playing for us and we'd still be a rabble.

_________________
"I'll tell you what I didn't do;
I never injected anyone."
AD 3/3/14

.
I'm happy to give credit to the development team for improvement of these young players which is most encouraging for supporters.

_________________
Bawditawaba

yeah cos judd is going to say he doesnt agree with the gameplan.. and he has a dream.. its to dislodge bret kirk and cameron ling from the all australian inside midfielders role...

im wth you club!!!

Im also sure he doesnt mind having a couple of years knocked off his 'best before date'...

yep yep.....

_________________
Due to recent budget cuts and the rising cost of electricity, gas, and oil....... the Light at the End of the Tunnel has been turned off. We apologize for the inconvenience.

And take away the 3 free kicks they got in front of goal and they would have kicked none

I dont see the Ling Kirk thing. He is playing similar to Ablett. I think that is a seed you planted in your own head a few weeks back and now its growing........in your own head.

So now you are saying there is a gameplan but its one you dont agree with ?

I am confused. Do you want me to take your word over Judds when it comes to football ?

The point is we got Judd (or at least that should have been the motivation) to be part, if not the biggest part, of our future, not to to be the sole focus. I winced slightly, though I let it pass, when someone at the top of the club said "I think we can build a side around Judd".

For instance, I'd rather have two of Angus Monfries than one Garry Abblet and a waterboy if it effectively means that you are forced to play the waterboy.

_________________
Just because I'm offended, doesn't mean I'm wrong.

PRO's

AJ - Wow. This kid is a SUPER find. Shut-down role to perfection. Not that i care, but i'd love to see him get a rising star nomination.

BOWER - Has not put a foot wrong this year and is the in-form player of the club. Consistantly wonderful week-in week-out.

FEV & JUDD - finding some much needed form after last week.

SETANTA - Loved his little tap on to Judd, then he ran back into space for judd to kick too (in the end, judd went elsewhere but it was good to see Setanta backing up his efforts rather than just saying 'oh well, i've done my bit).

FISHER - Good to see him back. Wasn't a fan of his last year, but hopefully he can step up this year.

MUPRHY - As good as always.

SETVO - Wow. I actually saw Stevens throw himself on the ball a couple of time. I really enjoyed watching his game. Well done.



CONS's:-

YES CAZZ, there are going to be some "Yeah, But's"...............

KICK INs - AWFULL! despicable. Atrocious. Have we done no work on these all year? It certainly doesn't feel that way. We take our time, which allows the opposistion to man up, then we always kick wide which most of the time, it ends up in a turn over and results in a goal. Why do i see no players leading for the ball? They stand there and wait for it to be kicked to them.

PLAYING THE FLANKS - We have Kreuzer as the only player who is a good tall who can take a contested grab, so why are we playing this 'kicking along the flanks' crap? It's awful. The times we we're kicking goals last night is when we moved it through the corridor and hit a leading forward. I fully believe if we kept playing like that we could have won by 100points.

WEST COAST AREN'T THAT GOOD - seriously, we beat a side that we should have thrashed. West Coast are re-building and we're trying to make a push for the finals. We should have pulverized them.

JORDAN RUSSELL - why am i even bothering to write this but.................who did he play on? I was told to watch him 'Carefully', which i did. All Night! I watched him go to ground 3 times, i watched him make endless mistakes, and i watched him run around On His Own for most of the game picking up a mere 11 possesions (10 of them uncontested, what does that tell you).
What Does He Do to deserve a spot in this team over Anderson or Bannister? Drop Him for god sake.



We have Brisbane (Away), St Kilda, Essendon* and Freo again.................... At the moment, i can see maybe 1 win based on our current style of play and form. 1 win will not keep us in the 8. Whilst i'm happy with the win, surely we can play better football than that! Because if we don't, i can't see us beating any of those teams we have coming up!

_________________
"We are what we repeatedly do. Excellence, then, is not an act, but a habit"
- Aristotle

Pros
Thought a big pro was Kade Simpson..... looked like he is getting back to his best

Cons
This thread being hijacked by the usual suspects. The way its going Pros and Cons will end up the same as Talking Players.

_________________
17 4 10

"At times, Hammer’s palming was superb" - i know i'm a nark, but again this week, like last week, gave away goals when he palmed towards their goal in their forward line. now that may be the instruction or the positioning by the intended palmees, but maybe a bit of logic here?

_________________
one you knock back is one you never have

we've got a bloke called kruezer - why won't he do?

_________________
one you knock back is one you never have

Take away judd and we have 14 less shots at goal.

Juddy was involved in 14 shots at goal. Unbelievable stat

And mark Robinson thought he wasnt worthy in being in the top 5 players on the ground
Absolute idiot

Mark Robinson is a con

We are 5th on the ladder with the 3rd best percentage in the comp

_________________
Cheats never prosper (except in the AFL)

We could .... if we had a main ruckman fit to replace him. You can't take him out of the ruck until we have a genuine replacement ... people talk about Judd giving drive out of the middle, Kreuz gives us almost as much ... a ruck and a midfielder rolled into one, 2nd and 3rd and 4th efforts, huge tank ... this kid is amazing.

If Warnock can hold down the ruck, then he comes back and you move Kreuz to the forward line ... straightens the team up, we can afford not being so Fevcentric, stop punting it up onto the head of short forwards. Suddenly structure and game plan are praised ... sorry, funny coloured glasses right?

Problem with this is that Kreuz wants to play on the ball and he wants that because he knows his contribution to the team is greater.

_________________
"It was like calling your ex girlfriend after a night on the booze, just a really bad decision".

Take away Judd and we would have struggled to beat the Eagles.

While we're at it why dont we take away:

Fred Stafford, Brian Kekovich, Ted Hopkins, Wayne Harmes - then we can return the 1947, 1968, 1970 and 1979 Premiership Cups.

_________________
"Hence you will not say that Greeks fight like heroes but that heroes fight like Greeks"?

Winston Churchill

I don't like that idea AGRO. Can we not do that please?