murraycray wrote:
If as reported, the candidate list is down to 4, then I hope either Barker or Dew get the gig. I think an AFL COACH should have played at this level. Primarily to have first hand knowledge of the pressure players are under, and how to react under that pressure.
This has come up a lot, and there is no right or wrong answer.
There have been examples given of other sports where the best coaches haven't necessarily played at that highest level. The fact that the AFL head coach role is now changing to a Managerial role, with so much delegated to others means we can't dismiss the comparison.
This is why the appointments around him are as equally important. Assistants, Development, High Performance, Recruitment etc.
Lloyd did make it to the VFL reserves, and we can't say whether or not it was not knowing how to cope with succeeding at the next step, that prevented him from going further.
On the flip side we have Jarrad Waite playing his 200th this week, and yet do you think he has any more of an idea than Bolton/Lloyd of passing on the knowledge of what is required to excel at this level....
Phil Walsh for example was doing a great job at Adelaide, but you wonder how much was due to him - like Lloyd - being in the AFL system in a variety of roles over 20 years, and how much due to play ing VFL football 30 years ago?
Unfortunately despite there not being many examples, the case against 'a Lloyd type' is there isn't one coach we can point to prove it can succeed. Brittain, McCartney, Craig, Todd and Cahill come to mind, but who knows how much of not playing at the highest level contributed to their "failures".
Lloyd and Bolton excite me as I believe they bring the combination of experience, yet freshness and hunger due to being first timers that this club needs. Similar to Walsh at Adelaide, Hinkley at Port, or Richardson at St Kilda.
Originally was liking the Dew/Nicks types, but not sure they have the experience to cope with what they will be walking into! Will be good coaches one day, and would slot into a West Coast or Western Bullldogs like Beveridge and Simpson have, but we are a different case all together.
Have no interest in second timers (McKenna, Sanderson etc), or those that might start question their passion 1 or 2 years in to what will be a mammoth task (Thompson, Worsfold etc).
As we've never done before it not about finding "the best coach", but the right coach to fit the clubs needs......